Through five lessons, students are introduced to all facets of the rock cycle. Topics include rock and mineral types, material stresses and weathering, geologic time and fossil formation, the Earth's crust and tectonic plates, and soil formation and composition. Lessons are presented in the context of the related impact on humans in the form of roadway and tunnel design and construction, natural disasters, environmental site assessment for building structures, and measurement instrumentation and tools. Hands-on activities include experiencing tensional, compressional and shear material stress by using only hand force to break bars of soap; preparing Jeopardy-type trivia questions/answers for a class game that reinforces students' understanding of rocks and the rock cycle; creating "fossils" using melted chocolate; working within design constraints to design and build a model tunnel through a clay mountain; and soil sampling by creating tools, obtaining soil cores, documenting a soil profile log, and analyzing the findings to make engineering predictions.
Engineering Connection
Engineers learn about the natural world in order to design the human-built environment. Rocks, soils, fossils and the Earth's crust make up the foundation of the world we depend upon. Engineers must understand the characteristics of these rocks and materials so that they can design big infrastructure projects—such as bridges, foundations, roads and tunnels—to be safe and long-lasting. Geotechnical engineers apply their understanding of rocks to environmental site investigations for the purposes of land development and environmental stewardship. To prevent and limit the destruction of communities and human life, engineers also develop technologies to assess and predict natural hazards caused by rock movement. Engineers apply their understanding of science and math to designing the tools and instrumentation for sampling, sensing, drilling, boring, analyzing and modeling—so we can learn more and predict better.
Unit Overview
Lesson 1 - Rock Solid: An introduction to the types of rocks and minerals, as well as material stresses and weathering
Lesson 2 - Making & Breaking: How natural weathering, erosion, pressure and heat are part of the rock cycle
Lesson 3 - Fantastic Fossils: Geoologic time and fossil formation
Lesson 4 - How Mountains Are Formed: The Earth's crust and tectonic plates as they impact roadways, tunnels, natural resource location and natural disaster prediction
Lesson 5 - Soil Investigations: Soil formation, composition and properties as seen in soil profiles and soil sampling for environmental site assessment
Subscribe
Get the inside scoop on all things TeachEngineering such as new site features, curriculum updates, video releases, and more by signing up for our newsletter!
PS: We do not share personal information or emails with anyone.
Integrated Teaching and Learning Program, College of Engineering and Applied Science, University of Colorado Boulder
Acknowledgements
This digital library content was developed by the Integrated Teaching and Learning Program under National Science Foundation GK-12 grant no. 0338326. However, these contents do not necessarily represent the policies of the National Science Foundation, and you should not assume endorsement by the federal government.
Rocks cover the earth's surface, including what is below or near human-made structures. With rocks everywhere, breaking rocks can be hazardous and potentially disastrous to people. Students are introduced to three types of material stress related to rocks: compressional, torsional and shear. They learn about rock types (sedimentary, igneous and metamorphic), and about the occurrence of stresses and weathering in nature, including physical, chemical and biological weathering.
Engineering Connection
Geotechnical engineers study rocks in the earth's crust. They conduct tests and simulations to predict volcanoes, earthquakes and rockslides. To avoid potential disasters that might occur if rocks fail, engineers routinely apply their understanding of rocks and soils prior to the construction of complex and costly structures such as airports, roads, dams, skyscrapers and tunnels. They identify underground rock types and predict their behavior under stress, as well as determine the best way to excavate them as part of the construction process.
Learning Objectives
After this lesson, students should be able to:
Describe the basic ideas of stress.
List the three different types of weathering.
Explain that not all rocks break the same way or with the same amount of pressure.
Describe how engineers are able to evaluate the strength of rocks.
Visit [www.teachengineering.org/curriculum/print/cub_rock_curricularunit] to print or download.
Introduction/Motivation
(Optional: Introduce the lesson using the Rock Solid Introduction PowerPoint presentation. Use the written text below as a script, with each idea correlating to one slide.)
We see rocks outside everyday, in both landscaping and nature. In fact, the entire earth is basically one gigantic rock! The earth's crust is entirely made of solid rocks, so there are huge rocks in the ground covering the entire planet! We cannot see many of these rocks. Sometimes dirt covers them and we must dig very deep to find them, but huge rocks cover the entire earth's crust, even under the oceans. That means that all of our buildings, all of our bridges, all of our roads, and even your home, are sitting on rock.
What might happen if some of these huge rocks broke? What types of natural disasters might be caused? What would happen to the bridge or skyscraper resting upon one of those massive rocks? These are questions that geotechnical engineers think about when determining locations to place structures. Geotechnical engineers understand what causes rocks to break. They know how to identify different types of rocks, and determine if a certain rock is likely to break. They work with structural engineers to plan the best way to build structures in different rock conditions.
Why Care about the Strength of a Rock?
The most important reason why we care about the strength of a rock is that when a large rock breaks, it can be a hazard and possibly cause a disaster. There are many different disasters caused by breaking rocks, including earthquakes, tsunamis, volcanoes, rock falls, and landslides. To protect structures and people, we want to be able to predict or prevent such disasters. If an engineer knows the characteristics of a particular rock type, she may be able to predict or prevent disasters.
Furthermore, a less serious reason why we care about the strength of rocks is for development, which means building and expanding the use of land (such as new shopping centers, schools or homes being built in a town). Many building plans require deep foundations, making it necessary to excavate or dig out rock. An engineer provides information about the best way to excavate the rock, so as to build an adequate foundation.
What Can Break Rocks?
When pressure is applied to an area, such as a rock, it is called stress. If you press your hands together, you can feel the forces of stress. In nature, stress can cause rocks to break, and one way that stress occurs is by the natural movements of the earth's crust (remember that the earth's crust is basically floating on liquid magma, and so it moves often). Refer to the associated activity Soapy Stress for a fun and hands-on approach to learn more about stress! There are three types of stress (see Figure 1).
Compressional stress is when a rock is pressed together into itself, like when crust movements cause two rocks to squeeze another one between them. Another example is when mountains are formed at a convergent boundary, like the Rocky Mountains. Press your hands together again. You can feel that the inner parts of your hands are being smashed by compressional stress from the muscles in your hands pushing inward.
Tensional stress is when a rock is pulled apart. For example, if a rock wedged itself into the crack of another rock, and movement of the earth's crust caused it to wedge even further until the rock broke apart. Another example is a divergent boundary, like the Mid-Atlantic Ridge, which is formed by two tectonic plates pulling apart from each other to allow lava to flow upward. Use one of your hands to pull a finger on your other hand. You can feel the tensional stress because your hand is pulling your finger one way, and your other hand is attached to your finger, pulling it the other way by holding it in place.
Shear stress is when a rock is pulled on one side but pushed on the other side. This can happen if the crust movements on one side of a rock are opposite of those on the other side of the rock. An example of this is the San Andreas Fault, which is on a transform boundary, with the California plate moving southward and the Pacific Ocean plate moving northward. Put your hands together again, but this time press upward with your right hand and downward with your left hand. If you press hard, you should notice that the skin on your right hand is being pulled down because of the forces from your left hand pulling down, and the skin on your left hand is being pulled up because of your right hand. (It may be easier to see the skin being pulled if you use an area on your body where the skin is looser, such as your hand pressing upward against your arm or cheek.)
In addition to stress due to the movement of the earth's crust, stress can come from weathering. Weathering is the breaking down of rocks into sediments (small bits of rock), due to conditions in nature. There are many types of weathering:
Physical weathering is when a physical action breaks the rock, such as the forces of wind or water. A common example is the freeze/thaw action of water in rock cracks. As the water freezes, it expands, causing stress (pressure) that breaks the rock. (Note: If students ask what kind of stress this is, tell them that the process is complicated and includes both tensional and compressional stress.)
Chemical weathering is when the rock is chemically broken down. Some common examples of this are rust forming on granite or acid rain breaking down limestone. This type of weathering is not considered a type of stress because there is no pressure on the rock (remember that stress is pressure applied to an area).
Biological weathering is when living organisms break the rock. A typical example is a tree root breaking a rock due to the stress caused by its pressure. (Note: If students ask what kind of stress this is, tell them that the process is complicated and includes both tensional and compressional stress.)
So, rocks in the earth are usually broken by either the stress from the movement of the crust or the stress from weathering.
Upon What Does the Strength of Rock Depend?
Not all rocks break from the same amount of pressure. Some rocks are easier to break than others. The strength of a particular rock depends on that rock's type, texture and chemical composition. It also depends on the presence or absence of fluids, or if there are internal structures.
Sometimes, it is possible to predict where a rock will break. Rocks often break along a plane of weakness, which is the weakest part of the rock's structure. Sedimentary rocks have planes of weakness along their bedding planes, or between the layers of sediment. Metamorphic rocks have planes of weakness along their foliation planes, which are layers or stripes formed from pressure. Observing these aspects helps us predict where a rock will break!
Figure 2. Geotechnical engineers drill to get rock core samples like these so that they can make observations and perform tests.
To discover all the factors that determine whether a rock might break, engineers use certain methods and equipment. They examine the rock's texture and structure. They drill to get rock samples, called core samples (see Figure 2). They test the sample's response to stress using special (and expensive) machinery. As a side note, one problem with testing samples is that rocks are not homogeneous, meaning one sample's response to the test may not necessarily be identical to the response of another sample taken elsewhere. After an engineer has fully examined and tested a rock, she gives it a safety factor for others to consider when building near the rock.
Lesson Background and Concepts for Teachers
What Makes Up Rocks?
Knowing what makes up rocks might help us understand their strength. Rocks are made of minerals. Rocks are classified into different types, depending upon their mineral composition and formation. First let's look at minerals.
A mineral is a solid material that exists naturally on earth, and is made of only one substance. Most minerals are made up of crystals, which are solid, 3D patterns made by the molecular structure. There are hundreds of different minerals, and they are classified by their chemical makeup and crystal shape. Some familiar minerals include: gold, silver, platinum, mercury, sulfur, graphite, mercury, diamond, talc, halite (table salt), calcite, galena (lead), magnetite, hematite, quartz and mica.
Minerals can be identified by conducting a series of tests, and comparing the results to charts of known mineral characteristics. The tests include finding their color, streak (the color of the mark they leave when you rub them on something), transparency, hardness, luster (shininess), cleavage (the specific way that they break) and crystal shape. Students can further investigate these properties with the associated activity Rocks, Rocks, Rocks: Test, Identify Properties & Classify.
What is the difference between a rock and a mineral? Rocks are made of two or more minerals. For example granite, a very common rock, is made of the minerals, feldspar, quartz, mica and hornblende, which can actually be distinctly seen in granite (see Figure 3).
Figure 3. The minerals that compose some rocks, like granite, are distinct and easily visible.
Besides its mineral components, a rock type is also determined by the way it was formed. The three basic ways that rocks are made are grouped as the three rock families: sedimentary, igneous and metamorphic.
Sedimentary rocks are made of sediments (small bits of old rock). Sediments come from the weathering and erosion of old rocks. Weathering is how rocks are broken down, usually from influences such as water and air. Erosion is the breaking down and movement of parts of the earth's surface (weathering is a type of erosion). Once sediments are broken apart from weathering and erosion, then pressure pushes them together (called compaction) to make a layer of rock. Cementation also holds sediments together, which is when salts crystallize as water is squeezed out. Later, other sediments get pushed into another layer of rock and eventually the layering, or bedding, continues to make one bigger rock. This process creates layers that are characteristic to sedimentary rocks (see Figure 4). Some common sedimentary rocks are sandstone, siltstone, limestone, conglomerate and shale.
Figure 4. Bedding, or layers, are characteristic to sedimentary rocks, such as those at Sandstone Needles in Canyonlands National Park, UT.
Igneous rocks are made of magma, which is molten rock (old rock that has been melted from pressure and heat under the earth's crust). Magma is called lava after it comes out of the crust (for example, when it comes out of a volcano). When the liquid magma or lava cools, it becomes hard, forming an igneous rock. The name "igneous" comes from the Latin word "ignis," which means fire. Different types of igneous rocks are formed if they cool slowly below the earth's surface (called intrusive) or quickly above the earth's surface (called extrusive). Some common igneous rocks are basalt, gabbro, granite (see Figure 3), pumice and obsidian.
Metamorphic rocks are formed from any type of existing rock. Pressure and heat change the actual molecules of a rock's minerals so that it becomes an entirely different rock (without melting, which would make it an igneous rock). The type of metamorphic rock formed depends on what type of rock it started out as. Foliation is when the pressure squeezes the minerals in a rock to create lines or layers. Foliation is a typical metamorphic rock characteristic (see Figure 5). Some common metamorphic rocks are gneiss, slate, marble and schist.
Figure 5. Foliation, which is when minerals are squeezed into lines, is characteristic to metamorphic rocks, like this gneiss.
You may have noticed in learning about the different rock families that all new rocks are made from old rocks. This is the idea behind the rock cycle (see Figure 6). For example, under certain geophysical processes, a metamorphic rock can be formed from a sedimentary and/or igneous rock. Likewise, all rocks can become every other type of rock given the right circumstances. The rock cycle describes the processes that allow the creation of new rocks from old rocks. [See the Develop Your Own Rock Cycle Worksheet that allows students to develop their own rock cycle].
Lesson Closure
So, why do we care about how rocks break? Rocks make up all of the earth's crust. It is natural for rocks to break, depending upon the stresses on them. When designing structures, engineers carefully examine the underground and above ground rocks before they build roads, homes or towers. How do we know if an area of land is safe to build around? Engineers identify rocks by close examination and testing samples under stresses. Since different rocks have different strengths, engineers can estimate how much stress a particular rock can handle.
In this lesson, we learned about what knowledge geotechnical engineers use to hypothesize about rocks. We learned that rocks break from stress, which can come from the earth's crust moving or weathering. We also learned that whether or not a rock breaks depends on many factors, and we can sometimes guess a rock's plane of weakness. Now that we know all this, we can predict if and how a rock might break, just like a geotechnical engineer!
Vocabulary/Definitions
compressional stress: When something is being pressed together.
earth's crust: (geology) The outer layer of the earth.
erosion: Natural processes that wear away material. Includes weathering, dissolution, abrasion, corrosion and transportation.
geotechnical engineer: A person concerned with the engineering properties of earth materials. They investigate the soil and rock below ground to determine its properties, and then design foundations for human-made structures built on the ground, such as buildings or bridges. They design structures built in or of soil or rock. They also assess the risk to humans, property and the environment from natural hazards such as landslides, debris flows and rock falls.
homogeneous: Uniform in structure or composition throughout.
igneous rock: (geology) A rock made of cooled magma (or lava), which is molten rock melted from pressure and heat under the earth's crust.
metamorphic rock: (geology) A rock formed from any type of existing rock, in which minerals are changed in structure or composition by pressure and heat. Examples: basalt, granite, pumice and obsidian.
mineral: A naturally-occurring, homogeneous inorganic solid substance having a specific chemical composition and characteristic crystalline structure, color and hardness. Examples: gold, silver, platinum, sulfur, graphite, diamond, talc, quartz and mica.
plane of weakness: An area of the weakest part of a rock's structure.
rock: A naturally-formed aggregate of mineral matter constituting a significant part of the earth's crust.
rock cycle: All new rocks are created from old rocks. Different rock types depend on their forming process.
rock falls: A fall of rocks, as from a cliff. Often caused by weathering.
sedimentary rock: (geology) A rock made by the deposition of sediment (small bits of old rock). Examples: sandstone, siltstone, limestone and shale.
shear stress: When something is being pulled one way on one side, and the opposite way on the other side.
stress: Pressure applied to an area. The three types are tensional, compressional and shear.
tensional stress: When something is being pulled apart.
weathering: Breaking down of rocks, due to such things as water, wind, acid rain and plants.
Assessment
Pre-Lesson Assessment
Brainstorming: As a class, have students engage in open discussion. Remind them that in brainstorming, no idea or suggestion is "silly." All ideas should be respectfully heard. Take an uncritical position, encourage wild ideas and discourage criticism of ideas. Have students raise their hands to respond. Write their ideas on the board. Ask the students:
Of what material(s) is the earth's crust made? (Possible answers: Rocks, dirt, etc.)
How do rocks break in nature? (Possible answers: Pressure, running water, freezing water, plant roots, weathering, rocks falling on rocks, actions of people.)
How would the breaking of a large rock affect people? (Answer: Lead students to the idea of earthquakes, structures falling, tunnel or foundation collapsing, volcanoes, rockslides, etc.)
Post-Introduction Assessment
Voting: Ask a true/false question and have students vote by holding thumbs up for true and thumbs down for false. Tally the votes and write the totals on the board. Give the right answer.
True or False: Under the ocean's floor, there are large rocks. (Answer: True. Large rocks cover the entire earth's crust, including under the oceans.)
True or False: Geotechnical engineers study buildings and how they stand. (Answer: False. They study rocks and the earth.)
True or False: Geotechnical engineers can guess if a rockslide might occur at a certain location. (Answer: True. These engineers know how to identify rocks and the ways they can break.)
Lesson Summary Assessment
Worksheet: Have students complete the Rock Solid Worksheet; review their answers to gauge their mastery of the subject.
Drawing: Have students draw a picture of each of the different types of stress. Ask them to draw arrows that show which way the pressure is acting and identify each type of stress. Have them draw another picture illustrating their choice of any example of weathering.
Lesson Extension Activities
Conduct the Adventure Engineering unit, Asteroid Impact, an 8-lesson unit in which student teams are posed with the scenario of an impending earth-crashing asteroid. They must design the location and size of underground caverns to save people from an earth that will be uninhabitable for one year. Student teams explore general and geological maps, determine the area of their classroom to help determine the cavern size required, learn about map scales, test rocks, identify important and not-so-important rock properties for underground caverns, and choose a final location and size.
Get the inside scoop on all things TeachEngineering such as new site features, curriculum updates, video releases, and more by signing up for our newsletter!
PS: We do not share personal information or emails with anyone.
References
Dictionary.com. Lexico Publishing Group, LLC., www. dictionary.com, accessed April 19, 2006. (Source of some vocabulary definitions, with some adaptation)
Fletcher, Kristin and Hodges, M.K.V. Earth Materials and Earth Cycles, Module 2, Part 1 Environmental Geology. Department of Geology, Idaho State University, http://wapi.isu.edu/envgeo/EG2_earth/EG-mod_2_prt1.htm, accessed April 19, 2006.
Geologic Hazards Slides, Volume 3 – Landslides, Tsunamis and Volcanoes. National Geophysical Data Center, National Oceanic and Atmospheric Association. Accessed April 24, 2006. http://www.ngdc.noaa.gov/
Glasscoe, Maggi. Forces in the Earth. Updated August 13, 1998. The Southern California Integrated GPS Network (SCIGN) Education Model. Accessed April 19, 2006. (Excellent simple animation showing compressional, tensional and shear stress) http://scign.jpl.nasa.gov/
Minerals Lesson. Volcano World, University of North Dakota, http://volcano.und.nodak.edu/vwdocs/vwlessons/Minerals/Minerals2.html, accessed April 19, 2006.
Rock Cycle and Rock Cycle Answers. Moorland School, Clitheroe, Lancashire, UK, http://www.moorlandschool.co.uk/earth/rockcycle.htm, accessed April 19, 2006.
Rocks, USGS Geology in the Parks. Updated January 13, 2004. U.S. Geological Survey, U.S. Department of the Interior. Accessed April 19, 2006. http://geology.wr.usgs.gov/
Megan Podlogar; Jacquelyn F. Sullivan; Malinda Schaefer Zarske; Denise W. Carlson
Supporting Program
Integrated Teaching and Learning Program, College of Engineering, University of Colorado Boulder
Acknowledgements
The contents of this digital library curriculum were developed under a grant from the Fund for the Improvement of Postsecondary Education (FIPSE), U.S. Department of Education and National Science Foundation GK-12 grant no. 0338326. However, these contents do not necessarily represent the policies of the Department of Education or National Science Foundation, and you should not assume endorsement by the federal government.
To experience the three types of material stress related to rocks—tensional, compressional and shear—students break bars of soap using only their hands. They apply force created by the muscles in their own hands to put pressure on the soap, a model for the larger scale, real-world phenomena that forms, shapes and moves the rocks of our planet. They also learn the real-life implications of understanding stress in rocks, both for predicting natural hazards and building safe structures.
Engineering Connection
Geotechnical engineers are concerned with the properties of earth materials. Their understanding of how rock behaves under stress is important for safety in our modern world. Engineers investigate above and below ground rock and soil to determine its characteristics, and then design foundations for human-made structures, such as bridges and stadiums. Their expertise helps build secure foundations for structures such as footings, piles, drilled piers and retaining walls. Their knowledge assures well-built dams, embankments, levees, mines and tunnels—all structures built with or in rocks and soil. Engineers also apply their expertise to assess the natural hazards risk to humans, property and the environment.
Learning Objectives
After this activity, students should be able to:
Describe stress as it relates to materials, such as rocks.
Identify and distinguish between the three types of stress.
Describe why engineers must understand the properties of earth materials.
Materials List
Each group needs:
1 regular-size bar of Ivory soap (Ivory is soft enough to break easily)
Visit [www.teachengineering.org/curriculum/print/cub_rock_curricularunit] to print or download.
Pre-Req Knowledge
Students should have some familiarity with stress and its three different types. See the Rock Solid lesson in the Rock Cycle unit for an introduction to rocks and stress; as a review, show students that lesson's Rock Solid Introduction PowerPoint® file.
Introduction/Motivation
Rocks cover the entire earth, and we need to know how they break. Who can tell me why? If we know how rocks break, then we can predict many types of natural hazards, which can, in turn, save structures or even our lives. Also, because we live on the earth and build structures on and in the earth, we need to know about how rocks break. Geotechnical engineers know all about rocks in the earth's crust. They know how to identify different rocks, and determine if a certain rock is likely to break. They do tests and simulations to predict volcanoes, earthquakes or rockslides. Geotechnical engineers also need to know how rocks break so that other engineers can excavate or dig into them to build the deep foundations or basements of buildings such as parking garages, bridge piers or skyscrapers.
Do you know how rocks break? Well, rocks break from stress. Stress is when pressure is applied to an area, such as a rock. There are three types of stress. Compressional stress is when something is pressed together, like when mountains form. Tensional stress is when something is pulled apart, like when a ridge such as the Mid-Atlantic Ridge is formed. Shear stress is when something is pulled one way on one side and the other way on the other side, like the San Andreas Fault.
Now that we've reviewed how rocks break, let's demonstrate these types of stresses ourselves! Using our own hands, do you think we could create enough stress to break a rock? Probably not! What are some things that we can break with our hands? Soap is a good model because with it, we can show the three different types of stress. Since we are not strong enough to break rocks, we can imagine that the bars of soap are rocks, and break them in different ways.
Procedure
Before the Activity
Figure 1: Pulling soap apart using tensional stress.
Tell the teams to have one person from each group try to pull a bar of soap apart with their hands, but tell them not to twist or bend, just pull (see Figure 2, see Troubleshooting Tips if problems pulling apart). Have students experiment and make observations, following along and completing their worksheets as they go.
Ask the class how they might demonstrate compressional stress using a piece of soap.
Figure 3. Using compression (pressed together pressure) to break soap.
Tell the teams to have one person from each group use one of the smaller pieces that resulted from the tensional demonstration, and press or squeeze it into smaller pieces, using either one (see Figure 3) or two hands (see Figure 4). Have students experiment and make observations, completing their worksheets as they go.
Ask the class how they might show shear stress using a piece of soap.
Instruct the class to have the third team member from each group break a piece of soap by pushing one way with his/her left hand and the other way with his/her right hand (see Figure 5). Have students experiment and make observations, completing their worksheets as they go.
Figure 5. Using shear stress to break soap. One hand pulls up, the other hand pulls down.
Bonus Problem (optional, for more advanced students). Ask the class how they might show combination stresses using a piece of soap. Have students experiment and make observations, completing the bonus problem on their worksheets. (Clue: Try bending a bar of soap to cause both compressional and tensional stresses, see Figure 6.)
If time permits, have students use their soap to demonstrate weathering and sedimentation of rocks, as described in the Activity Extensions section.
Conclude by holding a class discussion to compare results. Conduct the post-activity journal-writing assessment as described in the Assessment section.
Vocabulary/Definitions
compressional stress: When something is being pressed together. Causes a rock to shorten.
earth's crust: (geology) The exterior surface of the earth.
erosion: Natural processes that wear away material. Includes weathering, dissolution, abrasion, corrosion and transportation.
Geotechnical engineer: A person concerned with the engineering properties of earth materials. They investigate the soil and rock below ground to determine its properties, and then design foundations for human-made structures built on the ground, such as buildings or bridges. They design structures built in or of soil or rock. They also assess the risk to humans, property and the environment from natural hazards such as landslides, debris flows and rock falls.
godel: A small object that represents another, often larger object. Often used in testing or perfecting a final product.
rock: A naturally-formed aggregate of mineral matter constituting a significant part of the earth's crust.
sedimentary rock: (geology) A rock made by the deposition of sediment (small bits of old rock). Examples: sandstone, siltstone, limestone and shale.
shear stress: When something is being pulled one way on one side, and the opposite way on the other side. Causes rocks to slip past each other.
stress: Pressure applied to an area. The three types are compressional, tensional and shear.
tensional stress: When something is being pulled apart. Causes a rock to elongate, or pull apart.
weathering: Breaking down of rocks, due to such things as water, wind, acid rain and plants.
Assessment
Pre-Activity Assessment
Matching: On the classroom board, randomly write the three types of stress on the left side, the definitions in the middle of the board, and arrow diagrams for each stress on the right side of the board (see Figure 8). As a class, have the students match the correct pieces together (see Figure 8).
Figure 8. Example Matching pre-activity assessment activity.
Worksheet: Have students record their observations on the Soapy Stress Worksheet; review their answers to gauge their mastery of the subject.
Post-Activity Assessment
Journaling: Have students answer the following questions in a short paragraph:
Today we demonstrated the three different types of stress. How would some of these stresses occur on a bigger scale in the natural world? (Possible answers: Tectonic plate movement, earthquakes, volcanoes, landslides, rockslides, rock falls, etc.)
Why do geotechnical engineers need to understand stress in rocks? (Possible answers: To predict many types of natural hazards. To take steps to save structures and lives from natural disasters. To figure out the best way to excavate or dig into the earth and rocks, so we can construct deep foundations, retaining walls or basements for large structures such as bridges, dams, skyscrapers, stadiums and parking garages. To protect people from tunnel and mine cave-ins. Because we live on the earth and build structures on and in the earth.)
Safety Issues
Do not rub eyes after handling soap.
Rinse hands after handling soap.
Troubleshooting Tips
Make sure to have spare bars of soap for groups that break their soap into pieces too small to continue.
For the tensional demonstration, if students cannot break the soap by pulling it straight, have them try it with two people (see Figure 7). If they still cannot pull the soap apart straight, tell them to try bending it while pulling. Explain that the tensional stress is only present in the part of the soap that is being pulled apart. Bending the soap makes the top pull apart, while the bottom is pushed together. Where the soap is pushed together, there is compressional stress (see Figure 6). Bending the soap is an example of combination stresses (bonus problem).
Activity Extensions
Weathering Soap: Have students demonstrate weathering on their bar of soap by holding a sharp corner of the soap under running water. Over time, the sharp corner becomes rounded. Discuss how this is one way that a rock can be weathered by water—with an outcome of smoothing the rock. Have students seen examples of rocks weathered by water?
Sedimentary Soap: Have students attempt to create a sedimentary layer by smashing some of the small flakes of their soap together (compressional stress) to make a bigger piece of soap. Discuss how sedimentary rocks are made the same way, but from sediments instead of soap flakes.
Soap-Breaking Force: Ask students develop a way to compare or measure the amount of force needed for each type of stress in breaking of the soap. Have students think about which type of stress required the most force and how this relates to the amount of pressure needed to form different types of rocks.
Big Engineering Projects: Have students research the huge, human-made engineering projects currently under construction around the world right now, reporting to the class on what provisions were made to work with the site's natural earth, soil and rock conditions. To start, look at the Big Project Watch at the Civil Engineering Portal (http://www.icivilengineer.com/Big_Project_Watch/Big_Dig/) for links to amazing projects in progress around the world (tunnels, airports, river diversions, transportation systems, rail lines, highways, bridges, towers, sewer systems, irrigation systems, dams, tide barriers, nuclear waste repositories).
Activity Scaling
For lower grades, break the soap yourself along with the students, so they can watch the teacher before attempting to do it themselves, ensuring that they do it successfully. Also, eliminate the combination stresses challenge and explanation.
For upper grades, include a short discussion about the combination of stresses. Include this stress combination in the pre-activity assessment matching activity (see Figure 9). Also, make it a fourth challenge in the activity and require that students complete the worksheet Bonus Problem.
Get the inside scoop on all things TeachEngineering such as new site features, curriculum updates, video releases, and more by signing up for our newsletter!
PS: We do not share personal information or emails with anyone.
References
Big Project Watch. The Civil Engineering Portal, The Internet for Civil Engineers. Accessed April 19, 2006. http://www.icivilengineer.com/Big_Project_Watch/Big_Dig/
Dictionary.com. Lexico Publishing Group, LLC. Accessed April 19, 2006. (Source of some vocabulary definitions, with some adaptation)
Glasscoe, Maggi. Forces in the Earth. Updated August 13, 1998. The Southern California Integrated GPS Network (SCIGN) Education Model. Accessed April 19, 2006. (Excellent simple animation showing compressional, tensional and shear stress) http://scign.jpl.nasa.gov/learn/plate5.htm
Megan Podlogar; Jacquelyn Sullivan; Malinda Schaefer Zarske; Denise W. Carlson
Supporting Program
Integrated Teaching and Learning Program, College of Engineering, University of Colorado Boulder
Acknowledgements
The contents of these digital library curricula were developed by the Integrated Teaching and Learning Program under National Science Foundation GK-12 grant no. 0338326. However, these contents do not necessarily represent the policies of the National Science Foundation, and you should not assume endorsement by the federal government.
Continuing the Asteroid Impact challenge, student teams test rocks to identify their physical properties such as luster, hardness, color, etc., and classify them as igneous, metamorphic or sedimentary. They complete a data table to record all of the rock properties, and then answer worksheet questions to deepen their understanding of rock properties and relate them to the cavern design problem.
Engineering Connection
Civil and geological engineers, for example, design tunnels through rock, build roads on the sides of mountains, and construct skyscrapers rooted in soil and rock. It is imperative for these engineers to thoroughly understand the natural characteristics and properties of all types of rocks to ensure health and safety standards are met.
Learning Objectives
After this activity, students should be able to:
Gather data by performing scientific observation and testing of rocks.
Use the data and a flowchart to determine rock types and rock classification.
Identify rock types by distinguishing features.
Relate rocks-in-hand to geological formations on maps.
Relate the relevance of each tested/observed rock characteristic to designing/building caverns.
8 rock samples of the rocks listed on the Alabraska Geology Map: basalt, sandstone, limestone, granite, gneiss, slate, pumice, obsidian (not sand/gravel)
Visit [www.teachengineering.org/curriculum/print/cub_rock_curricularunit] to print or download.
Pre-Req Knowledge
A general familiarity with rocks and minerals.
Introduction/Motivation
Some rocks are not suitable for caverns. So, to determine the best place to locate your cavern, you need to get an understanding of the types of rocks and their properties throughout the varied terrain of the state of Alabraska.
Different rock types vary by region, so today you will be performing some rock tests so you can learn their properties, identify them and classify them as sedimentary, igneous or metamorphic.
Igneous rocks are formed directly from the cooling of magma and make up the majority of the Earth's crust.
Sedimentary rocks are often called "secondary" rocks, because they form from small pieces of other types of rocks, or from minerals that were previously dissolved in water (like the silt in lakes, rivers and seas). These are commonly found in dry areas.
Metamorphic rocks are those that have been changed over time due to different chemical surroundings, heat and pressure.
Procedure
Background Information
As necessary, supplement students' understanding of basic rock/mineral testing, rock identification, and rock classification (sedimentary, igneous, metamorphic).
The basic explanation of the rock cycle follows: Rocks are pushed deep into the Earth's surface, usually by tectonic motion, where they melt into magma. At a volcano, or anywhere magma is exposed to become lava (such as at divergent tectonic plates), the magma/lava cools to become igneous rock. Several processes may occur after this, for example kaolinization, which generates granite and other common igneous rocks. Metamorphic rocks are created in a different process than igneous rocks, a process that is characterized by high temperatures and pressures, changing the physical and chemical properties. These high temperatures and pressures are found in mountain-building events or through close proximity to igneous intrusions, where high temperatures exist from the cooling magma. Rocks exposed to the atmosphere suffer weathering and erosion, breaking into smaller fragments. The fragments accumulate, compress, and fuse to generate sedimentary rocks, such as limestone.
Before the Activity
Gather materials and make copies of the handouts.
With the Students
Start with a class discussion about rock properties and rock classification:
Describe the various rock characteristics: luster (how light is reflected), hardness (ability to resist being scratched), granular (texture of the specimen), porous (how many small holes/pores), color.
Describe the various rock names (refer to the Alabraska Geology Map) and the three rock classifications: sedimentary, igneous and metamorphic.
Illustrate the rock cycle and emphasize the different formation routes of the three main rock types. The following diagram is useful.
Distribute rock testing kits and handouts to each team. Three possible ways to distribute the rocks and conduct testing:
Quickest and most suitable for a mature class: Give each team all the rocks to test and discuss the results as a class after all testing and identification has been performed and recorded.
Give each group a different rock and after 5 minutes of testing, stop the class. Discuss the results using the flow chart and have the class chart each group's result.
Pass out one rock at a time to each group and allot 5 minutes to test, discuss and decide on its rock name. After 5 minutes, ask questions from the flow chart to guide students to the correct rock name and chart the results.
Students record rock characteristics in the data table.
Provide students with some information to classify the rocks as sedimentary, igneous or metamorphic, such as a textbook, website material or verbal explanation.
Have students refer back to the Alabraska map and have them identify the best area for their cavern to be built while referring to their worksheet answers.
Lead a concluding class discussion to review students' answers to the the worksheet questions, as described in the Assessment section.
Assessment
Worksheet & Data Table: Review students' data and answers on the Rock Test Data Table and Rocks, Rocks, Rocks Worksheet to gauge their mastery of the concepts. Refer to the Asteroid Impact Student Workbook Example Answers provided in the unit document for example data table and worksheet answers.
Concluding Class Discussion: After testing and recording is done and students have completed the worksheet questions, which are intended to give meaning and context to the rock properties, lead a class discussion to review those answers. Discussing the answers is beneficial to the overall project and to students' retention of rock property descriptions. Also ask students:
Why is it important to know rock properties before you build in it?
How might these characteristics affect your cavern? (Possible answers: A soft rock might cave in, an extremely hard rock might be too difficult to drill through, a porous rock might let water flood the caverns, etc.)
What is one way in which igneous rocks form?
What is one way in which sedimentary rocks form?
What does metamorphic mean?
Activity Extensions
Have students find geology maps for their state and determine the most common rock types present in their state or region. Applying their findings in this activity, have them determine the best locations to build caverns in their state.
Activity Scaling
For younger students, have the teacher do the testing in the front of the classroom (more of a class demo), asking questions from the flow chart. Then talk students through charting the results.
Subscribe
Get the inside scoop on all things TeachEngineering such as new site features, curriculum updates, video releases, and more by signing up for our newsletter!
PS: We do not share personal information or emails with anyone.
Adventure Engineering was supported by National Science Foundation grant nos. DUE 9950660 and GK-12 0086457. However, these contents do not necessarily represent the policies of the National Science Foundation, and you should not assume endorsement by the federal government.
Students learn the components of the rock cycle and how rocks can change over time under the influence of weathering, erosion, pressure and heat. They learn about geotechnical engineering and the role these engineers play in land development, the design and placement of new structures and natural disaster detection.
Engineering Connection
Geotechnical engineers belong to a branch of civil engineering; these engineers study the rocks and minerals in the earth's crust. They understand the rock cycle and the effects that a change in environment, including heat and pressure, might have on different rocks and soils. They use their knowledge to create technologies to help predict natural hazards, such as landslides and earthquakes, as well as assess the impacts and risks to humans associated with the development of housing and industrial areas.
Learning Objectives
After this lesson, students should be able to:
Draw a complete, labeled diagram of the rock cycle.
Explain why engineers must know about rocks when developing land or designing new structures.
Today we are going to learn more about something that you walk over every day—rocks! To get started, can anyone tell my why engineers need to know about rocks? Engineers must know about rocks, how they are formed, and how strong they are so that they can design safe buildings, tunnels and bridges for us. Engineers also use their knowledge of rocks to help determine and prevent natural disasters to humans from rock falls, landslides and earthquakes. These natural hazards can all be caused by breaking rocks.
How are rocks made? Can they change over time? This can be explained by understanding the rock cycle. Let's look at a diagram of the rock cycle together and talk about the different steps. (By paper handout or overhead projection, show students the rock cycle diagram in the Rock Cycle Handout-Overhead. Make sure they understand that the rock cycle continually repeats over many, many years.)
The cycle of recycling aluminum cans is similar to how the rock cycle works. The same material is continuously changed, reformed and re-used.
Weathering, erosion, cooling, melting, pressure, compaction, cementation, and heat are all factors that affect the breakdown and formation of rocks. Even though rocks seem so strong to us, they can be forced to change when their environmental conditions change. The three main types of rock can all change—igneous, sedimentary and metamorphic rock. All three types can be melted into magma under the earth's surface, which then hardens into igneous rock. Extreme heat or pressure can change rocks into metamorphic rocks. Rocks that are exposed to the atmosphere can undergo weathering and erosion to break into smaller pieces (sediment) that can be affected by pressure or cementation to form sedimentary rocks.
The rock cycle is a very slow cycle. Rocks might take a thousand years to change into another type of rock. In the rock cycle, rocks are continuously (although slowly) being changed from one form to another. The rock cycle proceeds in no particular order. For example, igneous rock can change into metamorphic or sedimentary rock over time, and metamorphic rock can become sedimentary or igneous.
Engineers use the rock cycle to help them understand the geology of region. Geotechnical engineers understand the rock cycle, what causes the rocks to break, and how a rock reacts when exposed to different environmental factors. These engineers are the people to contact when you want to develop a new area of houses or stores on land that has never been built upon before. These engineers are able to identify different types of rocks and soils in an area, and determine if the rocks may break if exposed to new forces, such as the pressure from vehicle traffic, structures and people. These engineers also study how changes to the area might cause unwanted side effects and risks to humans and property, such as landslides, unstable ground, and rock falls. In this way, they keep us safe by predicting and preventing natural hazards. Engineers must consider the environmental effects of their interactions with the earth and rocks, and how the addition of a structure or removal of some rocks might impact the stability of the area, increasing the risk of natural disasters and causing damage to structures over time. Following the lesson, students can play the fun game of Rock Jeopardy! through the associated activity to reinforce their understanding of rocks, the rock cycle and geotechnical engineering.
Lesson Background and Concepts for Teachers
The rock cycle explains the series of changes that rocks go though as they slowly are altered from one form into another. Key concepts for students to understand are that the rock cycle is a slow and continuous process, occurring over thousands of years, and that rocks change from one form to another under heat, weathering, erosion, melting, cooling, pressure, compaction and cementation.
The rock cycle is a continuous series of steps. For example: when igneous rock undergoes weathering and erosion it becomes sediment. Then, when that sediment undergoes compaction and cementation it becomes sedimentary rock. If that sedimentary rock becomes pressed together by heat and pressure, it can turn into metamorphic rock. Metamorphic rock, when it undergoes melting, becomes magma. That magma, when it cools, can become igneous rock—and the cycle continues!
In addition to going around the circle, changes in rocks can also occur across the circle—igneous rock can become metamorphic rock under heat and pressure, and metamorphic rock can become sediment under weathering and erosion.
While these concepts are fairly straightforward, it is worth taking the time to make sure that students can both draw the diagram of the rock cycle and explain the different steps. Additionally, you may need to review with the students the different processes that occur in the cycle: heat, pressure, melting, cooling, weathering, erosion, compaction and cementation. Refer to the Vocabulary/Definitions section and lesson 1 of this unit for explanations of several of these terms.
Lesson Closure
What have we learned today? What factors can affect rocks? What factors cause the breakdown and formation of rocks? (Collect answers from students: Weathering, erosion, cooling, melting, pressure and heat.) So basically, rocks can be forced to change when their environmental conditions change, and these changes can be described using the rock cycle. What is the order of the rock cycle? (Answer: The rock cycle goes in no particular order.) Explain to me how it works. (Answer: Rocks and minerals can go around the rock cycle in a circle, and changes to rocks can also occur across the circle. For example, igneous rock can become metamorphic rock under heat and pressure, and metamorphic rock can become sediment under weathering and erosion.)
Engineers use the relationships described in the rock cycle to help them understand the geology of an area of land. What do they want to find out? (Answer: Geotechnical engineers study the rock cycle, what causes rocks to break, and what reaction might occur when a rock is exposed to different environmental conditions, including heat and pressure.) Engineers use their knowledge of rocks and the rock cycle to create technologies to help predict and avoid causing natural hazards, such as ____________ and _______________ (Answers: landslides and earthquakes). They also evaluate the impacts and risks to humans and the environment that might be caused by our development of housing and industrial areas.
Vocabulary/Definitions
cementation: The act or process of cementing. Another part of how sedimentary rocks are formed is by sediment being glued together by natural glues such as calcite and silica. Compaction and cementation work together to create sedimentary rocks from sediment.
compaction: The act of pressing something together. Part of the way sedimentary rocks are formed is by sediment being compacted together.
erosion: The process by which the surface of the earth is worn away by the action of water, glaciers, winds, waves, etc.
magma: Molten rock inside of the earth.
sediment: Material deposited by wind, water or glaciers.
weathering: In geology, the various mechanical and chemical processes that cause exposed rock to decompose.
Assessment
Pre-Lesson Assessment
Warm up Question: Write the following question on the classroom board and have each student take a moment to write down their own answer. Walk around, looking at what students wrote, marking their answers if correct, and gauging the class' understanding of the subject. Consider making the "correct" mark by using a rubber stamp and a colorful ink pad.
Why do engineers need to know about rocks? (Possible answer: Because engineers must design strong foundations, structures, bridges and tunnels to keep us safe.)
Post-Introduction Assessment
Drawing: Ask students to draw the complete rock cycle, starting with blank paper. Remind them to include all the steps, and label all the arrows between the different parts of the cycle. Hint: Note the five main "stops" along the cycle, and nine arrows (as shown in the Rock Cycle Handout-Overhead). Next, review the entire diagram as a class to make sure that everyone has all the parts drawn in and correctly labeled. Help students fill in any missing parts of their rock cycle diagrams and review the entire cycle with the class.
Class Voting: Ask a true/false question and have students vote by holding thumbs up for true and thumbs down for false. Tally the votes and write the total on the board. Give the right answer.
True or False: Geotechnical engineers study the rock cycle. (Answer: True)
True or False: The rock cycle can help engineers predict natural hazards. (Answer: True)
True or False: All engineers use the rock cycle in their work. (Answer: False. Many engineers use the rock cycle, especially civil and geotechnical engineers. However, many other types of engineers do not use the rock cycle in their work.)
True or False: Engineers use the properties of rocks to determine the best place to build a structure. (Answer: True)
True or False: Geotechnical engineers determine the risks to humans, property and the environment from natural hazards. (Answer: True)
Lesson Summary Assessment
Where to Build It? Engage students in a discussion about how engineers use their understanding of the properties of rocks and the rock cycle when designing a structure, such as a house, a dam, or even a wind turbine. Have students look at the Rock Cycle Handout-Overhead. At what place on the rock cycle would provide the best conditions to build a structure? On sedimentary rock in an area that gets lot of rain? All rocks can change over time. As an engineer, what factors should you consider when choosing the best place to build a house? (Possible answers: Weather conditions, range of temperatures, types of rocks, etc.)
Lesson Extension Activities
Rock Cycle Race: As a timed race, ask two students at a time to volunteer to draw the rock cycle (appropriately labeled) on the board. The first student to correctly draw the entire cycle wins.
Research Project: Have students identify an engineering design (such as a specific bridge, tunnel or building) and research the particular issues its engineers would have needed to know about the rocks underlying the structure. Have students write a one-page report describing the structure, the rock formations under it, and the associated risks to the environment from the development of the structure (if any).
Subscribe
Get the inside scoop on all things TeachEngineering such as new site features, curriculum updates, video releases, and more by signing up for our newsletter!
PS: We do not share personal information or emails with anyone.
References
Barker, Rachel M. Collecting Rocks: Rocks Tell the Story of the Earth. Last modified June 24, 21997. U.S. Geological Survey. Accessed August 6, 2008.http://pubs.usgs.gov/gip/collect1/collectgip.html
Colorado Geology. Colorado Geological Survey. Accessed August 6, 2008. http://geosurvey.state.co.us/Pages/CGSHome.aspx
Dictionary.com. Lexico Publishing Group, LLC. Accessed August 6, 2008. (Source of some vocabulary definitions, with some adaptation)http://www.dictionary.com
Earthquake Hazards Program, Southern California, Pasadena, CA Field Office. Last Modified: July 30, 2008. National Earthquake Hazards Program. Accessed August 6, 2008. http://earthquake.usgs.gov/regional/sca/
Merriam-Webster Online. 2005-2006. Merriam-Webster, Incorporated. Accessed July 23, 2007. (Source of some vocabulary definitions, with some adaptation)http://www.m-w.com
The Rock Cycle Web Site: Cementation and Compaction. Last updated December 4, 2000. The Rock Cycle Web Site. Accessed August 6, 2008. http://www.personal.psu.edu/users/c/l/cll161/insys%20441/cementation.htm
The Rock Cycle Web Site for Teachers: The Toughest Sandcastle. Last updated December 4, 2000. The Rock Cycle Web Site. Accessed August 6, 2008. http://www.personal.psu.edu/users/c/l/cll161/insys%20441/sedimentation_act2.htm
Students reinforce their understanding of rocks, the rock cycle, and geotechnical engineering by playing a trivia game. They work in groups to prepare Jeopardy-type trivia questions (answers) and compete against each other to demonstrate their knowledge of rocks and engineering.
Engineering Connection
Engineers learn about the natural world in order to design the human-built environment. Rocks are important in the natural world, and make up the foundation of the earth we depend upon. Engineers must understand the characteristics and strength of the rocks located below the surface of the earth so that they can design safe structures, such as bridges, buildings, roads and tunnels. To prevent and limit the destruction of communities and human life, engineers also develop technologies to predict natural hazards caused by rock movement.
Learning Objectives
After this activity, students should be able to:
Explain that geotechnical engineers use their knowledge of the rock cycle to assist in the development of communities and prediction of natural hazards.
Demonstrate their understanding of basic rock facts, including the rock cycle, types of rocks, types of stresses placed on rocks, and engineering applications of the rock cycle.
Materials List
Each group needs:
5 index cards, labeled with incremental point values (100, 200, 300, 400, 500)
Pens or pencils
Textbooks or other resources about rocks to use as reference materials for writing questions and answers.
To share with the entire class:
5-10 index cards, labeled with category topic
Tape, to affix index cards to the board or wall
(optional) Rewards for each team (such as candy, pencils, stickers or other small prizes)
Visit [www.teachengineering.org/curriculum/print/cub_rock_curricularunit] to print or download.
Pre-Req Knowledge
Students should have a familiarity with the rock cycle and rock facts, including the types of rocks, rock stresses, and rock weathering factors.
Introduction/Motivation
We have been learning about rocks, the rock cycle and engineering. We have learned that geotechnical engineers are a type of civil engineer that study the rocks and minerals in the earth's crust. These engineers understand the way that rocks can change over time and the effects that those changes make on the surrounding environment. Engineers work to keep our communities safe by creating technologies to help predict natural hazards caused by the continual weathering and erosion of rock formations, such as landslides, mudslides, sinkholes and earthquakes. These engineers are also important in the design of housing and industrial areas. They identify different types of rocks and soils in the development location, and inform the planners on their expectations for whether the ground may change significantly if exposed to new forces, such as the pressure and forces from auto traffic, houses, structures, and a lot more people.
Are you ready to put into action all that you have learned so far about engineering and the rock cycle? Now that you have learned about how rocks are formed and changed, the steps of the rock cycle, and why engineers must understand the characteristics of rocks, you are ready to play Rock Jeopardy and test your knowledge!
Who knows the TV game show called Jeopardy? Who can tell me how it is played? (If students do not know, describe how a panel of contestants competes for prizes by being the first to supply the question for given answers in a variety of category topics.)
Today you will create your own questions and answers for our game of Rock Jeopardy. We'll break into teams, and each team will be responsible for creating five questions about engineering and rock types, the rock cycle, rock stresses, or other rock facts questions. When you are writing your questions/answers, make the hardness level of the question match with the point value. So, a 500-point question should be a lot harder than a 100-point one. Then, we'll play Rock Jeopardy together and see which team has the rock experts!
Procedure
Background
To provide a student review of the rock cycle and basic rock facts (including types of rocks, rock stresses and rock weathering), see information provided in lesson 1 and lesson 2 of this unit.
Before the Activity
Gather materials.
Write incremental point values on the front of the index cards (100, 200, 300, 400, 500).
Choose topic categories to which students will write questions, for example: Fun Rock Facts, Rock Types, The Rock Cycle, Rock Stresses, Rock Weathering, Where in the Rock Cycle?, Geotechnical Engineering, Materials Engineering, Engineering and Natural Disasters, Types of Engineering and Rocks, and Engineering Rocks! Write each topic on its own index card.
(Optional) To make sure engineering questions are included in the game, create and write out questions/answers for one engineering category in advance. See the attached Rock Jeopardy Example Questions/Answers for ideas for the "Engineering Rocks!" category.
Decide whether you want to run the game in the traditional television Jeopardy "reverse question" format or the easier question/answer format. In television Jeopardy, contestants are provided with an answer and must supply the question. They give their responses in the form of a question, such as "What is..." In this activity, the game is set up so students do not have to follow the "reverse question" format unless you feel it would work well for your class.
With the Students
Review the rock cycle and basic rock facts (including types of rocks, rock stresses, and rock weathering) with the students.
Explain the procedures and the rules of playing Jeopardy: Student teams pick a category and amount. The game show host (teacher) reads to the team the question on that card. The team has 30 seconds to consult amongst their team members and then give their answer. (Alternatively, conduct the game in the traditional television Jeopardy "reverse question" format if desired. Explain rules accordingly.)
Divide the class into teams of five students each, and give each team a set of five index cards.
Assign each team a category topic to which they write questions. Make sure all students have access to plenty of reference material to assist in writing questions.
Remind students that questions should increase in difficulty to reflect their point value.
Give students enough time (about 30 minutes) to brainstorm and write questions. Remind teams to write both the question and answer on the back of each index card.
Onto the classroom board or a wall, tape the question/answer index cards below a card with their category topic, in ascending points value order.
Explain the game rules: Once asked a question, teams may take up to 30 seconds to consult amongst themselves before answering. If a team does not answer the question correctly, the question goes to the next team, and then the next, until a team gives the right answer. Teams may choose any index card remaining on the board, in any order (except for those from the category for which they wrote the questions/answers). When all the index cards have been answered, the team with the most points (added from the front of the cards) wins.
Have teams sit together at tables, then play Rock Jeopardy!
Clarify questions/answers as the game proceeds.
Recognize the winning team with a reward.
Conclude by conducting the post-activity assessment described in the Assessment section.
Vocabulary/Definitions
Cementation: The act or process of cementing. Part of how sedimentary rocks are formed is by sediment being glued together by natural glues such as calcite and silica. Compaction and cementation work together to create sedimentary rocks from sediment.
Compaction: The act of pressing something together. Another part of the way sedimentary rocks are formed is by sediment being compacted together.
Erosion: The process by which the surface of the earth is worn away by the action of water, glaciers, winds, waves, etc.
Jeopardy: Risk of loss or injury; peril or danger. Also, name of a television game show.
Magma: Molten rock inside of the earth.
Sediment: Material deposited by wind, water or glaciers.
Weathering: In geology, the various mechanical and chemical processes that cause exposed rock to decompose.
Assessment
Pre-Activity Assessment
Practice Questions: To ensure that students understand the types of questions they will be writing, give them a few minutes and ask each student to create a practice question on a topic unrelated to rocks (perhaps Rock 'n Roll). (Example question: What is the name of the famous 1960s British rock group from Liverpool, England? Answer: The Beatles.) Have a few students share their questions and answers with the class and give the students feedback on their questions as needed, pointing out the range in difficulty in the example questions.
Activity Embedded Assessment
Observation: Evaluate students' questions/answers as they prepare them for the Rock Jeopardy game to gauge their comprehension of the subject matter.
Post-Activity Assessment
Engineering Exit Question: Have students each tell you one thing they learned about engineering and rocks as they leave the classroom.
Troubleshooting Tips
Make sure to clearly explain the rules and procedures of the game before starting. Also explain any reward structure.
It may help to assign a student(s) to serve as a timekeeper and/or scorekeeper.
Activity Extensions
If students want to play again, assign homework to write new questions/answers for new categories, and/or ask students to make the questions/answers more difficult.
Activity Scaling
For lower grades, create all of the questions/answers in advance.
For higher grades, have students select their own categories and develop questions/answers for that category. Make sure the categories are appropriate for Rock Jeopardy. Then run the game in the traditional reverse question format of the television show.
Subscribe
Get the inside scoop on all things TeachEngineering such as new site features, curriculum updates, video releases, and more by signing up for our newsletter!
PS: We do not share personal information or emails with anyone.
References
Dictionary.com. Lexico Publishing Group, LLC. Accessed August 6, 2008. (Source of some vocabulary definitions, with some adaptation) http://www.dictionary.com
Abigail Watrous; Kate Beggs; Kristin Field; Malinda Schaefer Zarske; Denise W. Carlson
Supporting Program
Integrated Teaching and Learning Program, College of Engineering, University of Colorado Boulder
Acknowledgements
The contents of these digital library curricula were developed by the Integrated Teaching and Learning Program under National Science Foundation GK-12 grant no. 0338326. However, these contents do not necessarily represent the policies of the National Science Foundation, and you should not assume endorsement by the federal government.
Students learn about fossils—what they are, how they are formed, and why scientists and engineers care about them.
Engineering Connection
Some engineers study fossils to learn about the prehistoric processes and functions that were present in the Earth's history. By understanding how prehistoric creatures lived and became extinct, engineers acquire new ideas for how to design ways to study global climate change and species extinction. Engineers also design the high-tech instrumentation that helps paleontologists discover fossils, especially at the microbial level; these technologies include MRIs, CAT scans and mass spectrometry (or spectroscopy). Engineers are integral to the development of current technologies that use fossils (and fossil fuels) for materials and energy production.
Learning Objectives
After this lesson, students should be able to:
Define fossil.
Describe how fossils are formed.
Explain why engineers might study fossils.
Introduction/Motivation
Today we're going to learn about some extremely old stuff—fossils! What are fossils? How are they formed? Why do scientists and engineers care about them? Let's start off with the definition of a fossil: Can anyone explain what a fossil is? A fossil is a remainder of something that lived a long time ago, such as an ancient plant or animal. Most fossils actually come from species that are now extinct.
Fossils help us learn about how the Earth, plants, and animals have changed over time. They also help us better understand the history of the Earth. Paleontologists (scientists who study fossils) can identify a time period for a certain fossil because the oldest fossils are the deepest buried. This makes sense because fossils are formed when soil covers a dead organism, and the hardest parts of the organism leave an imprint in the soil. So, over time, the soil covers more and more organisms, piling on top of the older fossils.
How is engineering related to fossils? Engineers are always trying to get new ideas and be inspired by things. By studying fossils, they can better understand how the prehistoric world worked, and find out details about specific processes. For example, studying pterodactyl bones can help a paleontologist understand exactly how the pterodactyl was able to fly. Engineers can compare and contrast the pterodactyl flying process to other flying methods. They might ask questions such as: Is there anything different and beneficial that the flight process includes? Is the pterodactyl flight process more efficient than other flight processes in any way? Is there anything in the pterodactyl flight process that we should avoid? How successful was the pterodactyl flight process? Engineers ask these types of questions to improve designs for current technologies. When engineers use processes from nature to improve a modern technological process or object, we call it biomimicry.
Engineers design the tools that help discover fossils. Paleontologists once only used hand picks and magnifying glasses to locate fossils. Now they use advanced tools such as magnetic resonance imaging, computer-assisted tomography, and mass spectrometry. Engineers also are involved in the design of technologies that create three-dimensional images of whole organisms from the two- dimensional imprints of fossils. To animate these new 3D images, they study the parts of the organism to discovery how the organism may have moved. Also, the instrumentation used to create chemical models of organisms from fossils is developed by engineers. Chemical analysis of fossils can help us learn more about the environment in which the organism lived, the diseases during that time, and what the organism used for food. Lastly, engineers can also use fossils and fossil fuels to create materials and energy that we use every day.
Lesson Background and Concepts for Teachers
What is a fossil?
A fossil is a remainder of something that lived a very, very long time ago. It can be the image of a plant, animal or even just the trace of an animal, such as its dung or tracks. Refer to the Fossil Fondue activity to have students learn more about how fossils are created by forming their own using small toy figures and melted chocolate.
How are fossils formed?
Animal fossils are formed when an animal dies and slowly becomes covered with soil, mud or silt. Over thousands and thousands of years, the animal decomposes and the hard parts of the body become replaced with minerals; this process is called permineralization.
Fossils are often found in sedimentary rock, which is formed by the layering of material over many years. When plants and animals die, they often sink to the bottom of a river or lake, where they are eventually covered over with soil and/or rock particles. Over time these soil and rock layers slowly become pressed together into hard rock, trapping the plant or animal remains between the layers, as fossils.
Potential fossils: What in our world today will be found as fossils in the future?
Because sedimentary rocks form in layers, scientists believe that fossils also form in layers from the oldest fossil to the youngest fossils. So, the fossils at the bottom of a deep layer of rock are most likely the oldest; the fossils toward the top of a rock are most likely the youngest. Scientists call this the "Law of Superposition."
Just as it makes sense that the fossils at the bottom of a rock would be the oldest, it also makes sense that the sediment that covers up organisms (that later become fossils) would be laid down in horizontal layers. This is called the "law of original horizontality." But, we know that over time, these horizontal layers can shift. Sometimes, sedimentary rock layers are not horizontal, but have been moved or shifted due to some change in the Earth.
How do fossils help us learn about the history of the Earth?
Scientists describe the Earth's long history in time periods that compose a geologic time scale. Time periods are broken up into eons, which are further divided into eras, which are then divided into periods, which are then divided into epochs.
Engineers study fossils from all over the geologic time scale. They look closely at the processes and functions that are found in prehistoric nature and apply them to current technologies. By understanding how prehistoric creatures lived and what caused them to become extinct, engineers can get new ideas for how to design something. Engineers can also use this information to create models of global climate change over the life of the Earth, as well as learn more about species extinction.
Engineering Tools
Engineers design the tools that paleontologists use to discover fossils. Examples include:
Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI): A noninvasive diagnostic technique that produces computerized images of internal body tissues and is based on nuclear magnetic resonance of atoms within the body induced by the application of radio waves.
Computer-assisted tomography (CAT scan): A medical imaging method in which digital geometry processing generates a 3D image of the internals of an object from a large series of 2D x-ray images taken around a single axis of rotation; used in many fields for nondestructive materials testing, including detecting cracks in aircraft skins, industrial pipes, underground pipes, corroded reinforcing steel inside concrete, leaking welds, finding broken wires in suspension bridges, and forensics, etc.
Mass spectrometry (or spectroscopy): An instrumental method for identifying the chemical constitution of a substance by means of the separation of gaseous ions according to their differing mass and charge, for identifying unknown compounds to determine physical, chemical or biological properties of compounds.
Lesson Closure
Who can tell me: What is a fossil? A fossil is a remainder of an organism that has been preserved in the Earth. What are different types of fossils? Fossils can be from a plant or animal, and they can even be footprints or droppings. Remember that fossils are formed when an organism dies and is covered in soil, fossilizing the hard parts of the remains. Remember that engineers design creative tools to help us find fossils. They also study fossils to get new ideas. They design technologies to help create physical and chemical images of fossilized organisms. This helps us learn about the physical structure of the organism, the environment that it lived in, the diseases that affected it, and what it used for food. Engineers also use fossils and fossil fuels to create materials and energy that we use every day. So, next time you look at a fossil, think about whether there is any way you can apply what you observed to a current technology!
Vocabulary/Definitions
biomimicry: Copying or imitating the special characteristics of naturally existing things (animals, plants, etc.) in human-made designs, products and systems. From bios, meaning life; and mimesis, meaning to imitate.
body fossil: A fossil of an organism's body.
chemical fossil: Also called biomarkers – a chemical trace of an organism.
engineer: A person who applies his/her understanding of science and math to creating things for the benefit of humanity and our world.
extinct: No longer existing.
fossil: A remainder of an organism that has been preserved in the Earth's crust.
geologic time scale : A scientific method for classifying historical time periods.
macrofossil: A larger fossil specimen, one large enough to be observed by direct inspection.
microfossil: A fossil that can be studied only microscopically, and that may be either a fragment of a larger organism or an entire tiny organism.
paleontologist: A person who studies fossils.
paleontology: The study of fossils.
permineralization: The process whereby groundwater permeates an organism and minerals from the groundwater precipitate out and fill the empty spaces in the body, thus forming a body fossil.
trace fossil: A fossil that shows the activity of an animal or plant but is not formed from the organism itself. A trace fossil shows that an organism was present. Examples: burrows, trails, footprints or droppings.
Assessment
Pre-Lesson Assessment
Discussion Question: Ask students the following question and discuss as a class. First see if students can provide a definition before explaining it to them.
What is a fossil? (Answer: A remainder of something that lived a long time ago, such as a prehistoric plant or animal.)
Post-Introduction Assessment
Class Vote: Ask several true/false questions about the lesson material and have students vote by holding thumbs up for true and thumbs down for false. Tally the votes and write the totals on the board. Give the right answer. Example questions:
True or False: A piece of animal droppings (poop) can be a fossil. (Answer: True. This type of fossil is called a trace fossil because it shows that an organism was there.)
True or False: Fossils are formed when people place them into sand for other people to find later. (Answer: False. Fossils are formed by sedimentary rock being formed on top of and around a dead organism.)
True or False: Paleontology is the study of fossils. (Answer: True)
True or False: Engineers have no use for studying fossils. (Answer: False. Engineers can get ideas from studying fossils. They can use what they learn about fossils to design new technologies that mimic the prehistoric natural world.)
Lesson Summary Assessment
Creative Writing: Have each student write an essay or letter from the perspective of a plant or animal that becomes fossilized and then is discovered by an engineer. Have them describe in detail how the plant or animal becomes a fossil, and how they are re-discovered after many years. Then have them explain what they helped the engineer to learn and maybe even a new technology that they influenced the engineer in designing. Award extra points for creativity.
Lesson Extension Activities
Arrange a field trip to a natural history museum so students can see examples of fossils.
If you live near a dinosaur dig or other historical dig area, arrange a field trip to a dig site. With advance reservations, some sites allow students to participate in the dig.
Scientists who study fossils are called paleontologists. Have students research what a paleontologist does and give an oral presentation, "A Day in the Life of a Paleontologist."
Ask students to research magnetic resonance imaging, computer-assisted tomography, and mass spectrometry, reporting back to the class a description of what these tools do for us.
Subscribe
Get the inside scoop on all things TeachEngineering such as new site features, curriculum updates, video releases, and more by signing up for our newsletter!
PS: We do not share personal information or emails with anyone.
References
Acorn Naturalists: Resources for the Trail and Classroom. Acorn Naturalists, Tustin, CA. www.acornnaturalists.com. Accessed May 17, 2007.
The Busasaurus. Scholastic, Inc. htttp://content.scholastic.com/browse/article.jsp?id=1636, accessed May 17, 2007.
Edwards, Lucy E. and John Pojeta, Jr. Fossils, Rocks and Time: Table of Contents. Last updated August 14, 1997. US Geologic Survey, US Department of the Interior. Accessed May 17, 2007. http://pubs.usgs.gov/gip/fossils/contents.html
Finding Fossils. Dinosaur Dig, San Diego Natural History Museum. Accessed May 17, 2007. http://www.sdnhm.org/archive/kids/dinosaur/index.html
Follow a Vertebrate: Excavation. Denver Museum of Nature & Science. Accessed May 17, 2007. http://www.dmns.org/main/minisites/fossil/vertexc.html
Fossil. Last updated May 17, 2007. Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia. Accessed May 17, 2007. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fossil
Fossils, Rocks and Time: Fossil Succession. Last updated August 14, 1997. US Geologic Survey, US Department of the Interior. Accessed May 17, 2007. http://pubs.usgs.gov/
Fossils, Rocks and Time: Introduction. Last updated June 26, 1997. US Geologic Survey, US Department of the Interior. Accessed May 17, 2007. http://pubs.usgs.gov/
Geological Engineering. The Princeton Review. www.princetonreview.com. Accessed May 17, 2007.
Krystek, Lee. What is a Fossil? The UnMuseum. www.unmuseum.org. Accessed May 17, 2007.
Merriam-Webster Online. 2007. Merriam-Webster, Incorporated. www.m-w.com. Accessed May 17, 2007. (Source of some vocabulary definitions, with some adaptation)
Paleontology Careers: I Want to Be a Paleontologist! Advice for Students and Parents. Paleontological Research Institution, Ithaca, NY. www.priweb.org. Accessed May 17, 2007.
Shepherd, Roy. What is a fossil? How do fossils form? Where can I find fossils? Fossils: Bringing the Prehistoric World to Life, Adventure Experiences. www.discoveringfossils.co.uk. Accessed May 17, 2007.
Abigail Watrous; Megan Podlogar; Malinda Schaefer Zarske; Denise W. Carlson
Supporting Program
Integrated Teaching and Learning Program, College of Engineering, University of Colorado Boulder
Acknowledgements
The contents of this digital library curriculum were developed under grants from the Fund for the Improvement of Postsecondary Education (FIPSE), U.S. Department of Education and National Science Foundation (GK-12 grant no. 0338326). However, these contents do not necessarily represent the policies of the Department of Education or National Science Foundation, and you should not assume endorsement by the federal government.
Use melted chocolate to learn about the fossilization process!
Summary
To understand how fossils are formed, students model the process of fossilization by making fossils using small toy figures and melted chocolate. They extend their knowledge to the many ways that engineers aid in the study of fossils, including the development of tools and technologies for determining the physical and chemical properties of fossilized organisms, and how those properties tell a story of our changing world.
Engineering Connection
Engineers design tools to help us learn about our natural world and how we can help people thrive. As fossils are uncovered, and previously unknown organisms are discovered, engineers learn how our world is changing. Fossil discoveries inspire the development of advanced engineering technologies to locate and even create 3-D images of prehistoric organisms. Engineers recreate how these organisms may have moved to get new ideas for new technologies or processes. By searching out the physical and chemical changes to the environment, engineers apply their knowledge to create processes to address global warming, as well as develop products that mimic prehistoric capabilities.
Learning Objectives
After this activity, students should be able to:
Define fossil.
Describe how fossils are created.
Explain why an engineer might study fossils.
Utilize the design process to develop and systematically compare ideas for tools that perform one or more of the following objectives: extract fossils, investigate the physical and/or chemical properties of fossils, or prevent future extinctions.
Materials List
Each group needs:
One small paper cup (Dixie cup size)
About ½ cup milk chocolate chips
Clean, small object from which to create a fossil impression (such as a plastic toy dinosaur); the object should be just the right size to fit in the paper cup, and not much smaller
Clean container, in which to melt chocolate
Spoon
Sharp knife
For the entire class to share:
Hot plates or a microwave
Refrigerator
Paper towels
Sink and water (for clean up)
Pre-Req Knowledge
Familiarity with the concept of fossils and how they are formed, as provided in the Fantastic Fossils lesson.
Introduction/Motivation
How do we know about plants and animals that lived on Earth thousands of years ago? What is a fossil? A fossil is a remainder of something that lived a long time ago. Many times, fossils can be imprints of footprints or bones. To make a fossil, a footprint or a dead animal or plant first gets covered with soil, mud or silt. Eventually, the organism decomposes and the hard parts (such as the bones) are left to make an imprint in the soil.
Today, we will make our own fossils. (Show an example of a toy that students will use to make an imprint.) When we make a fossil from this, how is it different from a real fossil? (Collect student answers.) In the natural world, all parts of the dead organism would decompose so fast that a fossil would not be formed looking like a whole animal. Bones take much longer to decompose, and so fossil imprints are often found of just the bones of an organism or the structure of a plant. (If available, show examples of real fossils, or photographs of them.)
How do engineers help us find fossils? How do they help us learn more about fossils? Well, there are several ways. First, engineers design advanced tools to help us locate and remove fossils from rocks and soil. These tools include magnetic resonance imaging, computer-assisted tomography, and mass spectrometry. Engineers design computer programs that create three-dimensional images and models of whole organisms from the two- dimensional imprints of fossils. Then, engineers might study fossilized organisms and their three-dimensional animated images to determine if there are prehistoric processes that could enhance or improve current technologies. For example, fossilized microbes found around a certain plant imprint might give the engineer an idea for a whole new process to help with agriculture or farming.
Fossils can give clues to how a region's environment changed over time, and engineers can use this information to create models of global climate change over the life of the Earth. Engineers can even use the knowledge from fossils to develop processes to address global warming and species extinction. Also, engineers are deeply involved in the development of technologies that use fossils (and fossil fuels) for materials and energy production.
Today, we are going to focus on the process of how fossils are made, and we'll ignore the fact that most of the organism would be decomposed. So, imagine this is a dying organism, and he falls to the muddy ground. Eventually, let's say this organism gets covered by more mud. Over time, the mud hardens so we can break open the mud and observe the fossil (ignoring the now decomposed organism). Let's model this exact process, using chocolate instead of mud!
Procedure
Before the Activity
Gather materials and set up hot plates or microwave.
Divide the class into teams of two students each.
With the Students: Part 1
Melted chocolate represents mud in which a dinosaur could have fallen dead.
If using a microwave to melt the chocolate: Heat about 2 cups of chocolate chips for 30 seconds intervals, stirring between heating intervals, until smoothly melted. Continue melting batches of 2 cups of chips until there is enough melted chocolate for everyone.
If using hot plates to melt the chocolate: Have each group melt their own chocolate over medium-high heat, continuously stirring. After the chocolate is melted and smooth, direct students to turn off the hot plates.
Fill the paper cup about half-way with melted chocolate.
Place the toy in the cup, oriented it so it is entirely, or nearly, covered in chocolate.
Top off the cup with melted chocolate, as needed.
Refrigerate the cups for at least one hour.
With the Students: Part 2
Hardened chocolate represents dried, solidified mud (rock), in which a fossil may be hidden.
After at least an hour in the refrigerator, tear away the paper cups from the hardened chocolate.
Use a knife to carefully cut the chocolate in half, along a plane that creates the best looking fossil (based on where the toy was placed in the chocolate).
Carefully pull the toy out of the chocolate, preserving the fossil as much as possible.
Ask students the embedded assessment observation questions provided in the Assessment section. Make sure students observe the fossils before eating them!
Conclude the activity by leading the post-activity assessment about the thinking behind designing engineering instruments for fossils, as described in the Assessment section.
Vocabulary/Definitions
computer-assisted tomography (CAT scan): A medical imaging method in which digital geometry processing generates a 3-D image of the internals of an object from a large series of 2-D x-ray images taken around a single axis of rotation; used in many fields for nondestructive materials testing.
engineer: A person who applies his/her understanding of science and math to creating things for the benefit of humanity and our world.
fossil: A remainder of an organism that has been preserved in the Earth's crust.
geologic time scale: A scientific method for classifying historical time periods.
macrofossil: A larger fossil specimen, one large enough to be observed by direct inspection.
magnetic resonance imaging (MRI): A noninvasive diagnostic technique that produces computerized images of internal body tissues and is based on nuclear magnetic resonance of atoms within the body induced by the application of radio waves.
mass spectrometry (or spectroscopy): An instrumental method for identifying the chemical constitution of a substance by means of the separation of gaseous ions according to their differing mass and charge, for identifying unknown compounds to determine physical, chemical or biological properties of compounds.
microfossil: A fossil that can be studied only microscopically, and that may be either a fragment of a larger organism or an entire tiny organism.
model: (verb) To simulate, make or construct something to help visualize or learn about something else (as the living human body, a process or an ecosystem) that cannot be directly observed or experimented upon. (noun) A representation of something, sometimes on a smaller scale.
paleontologist: A person who studies fossils.
paleontology: The study of fossils.
Assessment
Pre-Activity Assessment
Classroom Review: Ask students the following review questions and discuss their answers, as needed:
What is a fossil? (Answer: A remainder of a once living organism.)
How are fossils formed? (Answer: Fossils are formed when once-living organisms are pressed between layers of sediment as sedimentary rock forms)
Why do engineers care about fossils? (Answer: Engineers learn from fossils. Engineers design technologies to help locate and create three-dimensional imaging of fossils. Fossils can give engineers clues to how things used to work, and engineers can use the knowledge from fossils to develop processes that could help people and the environment today.)
Activity Embedded Assessment
Observation & Discussion: Have students carefully observe their fossils before eating them. Lead them to consider these open-ended questions:
Did your toy leave a perfectly shaped fossil? If not, why not?
What similar problems might engineers have when designing instruments to help paleontologist locate fossils?
Pretend you never saw the toy. What are the physical properties of your fossil? What might your fossil tell you about how the organism lived?
Can you think of a way to apply that to a certain technology? (For example, looking at a pterodactyl fossil, you can tell that it uses certain bones to help it fly. Maybe this method of flight can be applied to airplanes somehow.)
How can what we learn from the past impact what we do today?
Post-Activity Assessment
Engineering Instruments for Fossils: Have students consider the engineering development of technologies for determining the physical and chemical properties of their fossilized organisms. Assign students one of the four following problems (bullet point list), with the aim of each group having a similar number of students. Students should individually brainstorm and sketch a design for a new technology to help with their assigned problem. Then, have students come together into 4 groups (one for each problem) to explain their ideas to each other, and compare designs systematically to evaluate how each tool might perform given the criteria and constraints of the problem. Each group can then present their preferred solution and its merits to the entire class.
Finding the fossils: Think about what you used to locate your fossil in the chocolate "mud." Then brainstorm a better way to remove the fossil from the mud. Design a specialized tool for removing the fossil? What would it do?
Physical modeling: Think about the physical properties of your fossil. What does this tell you about the environment during that time? Engineers help us develop three-dimensional models of fossils. If you were to animate a three-dimensional model of your organism, how might it move? Design an instrument that would help you learn about the physical properties of your fossil.
Chemical modeling: What are some chemical properties that you would want to know about your fossil? What could this information tell you about the environment at the time? Design an instrument to determine the chemical properties of fossils. What would it look for?
Changing world: Think about how physical and chemical properties tell a story of our changing world. List any chemical and physical properties from your fossil and come up with a story of the extinction of your fossil's species. Then, design a possible process that considers this extinction and how engineers could help prevent similar extinction in the future.
Exit Question: Have each student tell you one new thing they learned today before leaving the classroom. This can be done while students are seated (which allows other students to hear their answers) or as they exit the classroom (which can be effective, but can also create a bit of a traffic jam).
Safety Issues
Make sure that the small objects, melting containers, spoons and knives are clean enough from which to eat.
Make sure that students understand the dangers of the hot plates and the hot chocolate so they do not get burned.
Direct students to be careful with the sharp knives.
Troubleshooting Tips
Allow enough time for the chocolate to completely harden (about one hour in the refrigerator).
Make sure the object is not so small that finding the cutting plane is too difficult.
To preserve the best fossils possible, have students take their time when cutting open the fossils.
Activity Extensions
To create more permanent fossil models, have students create fossils using plaster of paris, and then paint and label them.
Lead a class discussion: What sorts of history should different types of engineers be familiar with? (Discussion points: Historical knowledge is vital to all professions — doctors, lawyers, bankers, teachers, etc. Fossils help engineers learn about the history of the Earth, and engineers need to know about the history of their field of study. For example, aerospace engineers must know about the history of flight, and how the Wright brothers learned how to design airplanes. Biomedical engineers must understand the history of the first prosthetics, and mechanical engineers must know about early steam engines. Understanding the past — the history of engineering and technology — helps us be better engineers today and in the future.)
Ask students to research magnetic resonance imaging, computer-assisted tomography, and mass spectrometry, reporting back to the class a description of these creative tools designed by engineers, and how they can help us.
Activity Scaling
For younger students, do not cover the objects entirely with chocolate, but instead just halfway embed them on their sides into a shallow plate of melted chocolate. After cooling, simply remove the object to reveal its fossil.
For older students, make the excavation more challenging. Use larger paper cups, and have them place the objects entirely submerged in the chocolate randomly (not neatly and straight). After cooling, pass the cups back out randomly so that each team does not know where to look for the object in the chocolate. This requires them to be even more careful in excavation so as not to ruin the fossil. Allow more time for this alternative.
Subscribe
Get the inside scoop on all things TeachEngineering such as new site features, curriculum updates, video releases, and more by signing up for our newsletter!
PS: We do not share personal information or emails with anyone.
References
Acorn Naturalists: Resources for the Trail and Classroom. Acorn Naturalists, Tustin, CA. Accessed May 17, 2007. http://www.acornnaturalists.com/
Merriam-Webster Online. 2007. Merriam-Webster, Incorporated. Accessed May 17, 2007. (Source of some vocabulary definitions, with some adaptation) http://www.m-w.com
Abigail Watrous; Megan Podlogar; Malinda Schaefer Zarske; Denise W. Carlson
Supporting Program
Integrated Teaching and Learning Program, College of Engineering, University of Colorado Boulder
Acknowledgements
The contents of these digital library curricula were developed by the Integrated Teaching and Learning Program under National Science Foundation GK-12 grant no. 0338326. However, these contents do not necessarily represent the policies of the National Science Foundation, and you should not assume endorsement by the federal government.
Students investigate how mountains are formed. Concepts include the composition and structure of the Earth's tectonic plates and tectonic plate boundaries, with an emphasis on plate convergence as it relates to mountain formation. Students learn that geotechnical engineers design technologies to measure movement of tectonic plates and mountain formation, as well as design to alter the mountain environment to create safe and dependable roadways and tunnels.
Engineering Connection
Engineers create tunnels through mountains for transportation purposes. Before constructing a mountain tunnel, geotechnical engineers bore test holes into the mountain rock to sample and analyze the material that will be bored or drilled into during tunnel construction. To succeed with these big projects, engineers must have a solid understanding of the drilling process, and the composition and features of the mountain of interest—both of which are determined during the mountain's ancient formation.
Learning Objectives
After this lesson, students should be able to:
Explain the connection between tectonic plates and mountain formation.
Describe several types of technologies designed by engineers that are related to mountain formation, including tools and processes for measuring formation, predicting natural hazards, and determining the location of natural resources.
Visit [www.teachengineering.org/curriculum/print/cub_rock_curricularunit] to print or download.
Pre-Req Knowledge
Students should have some familiarity with the existence of tectonic plates, that they move and the various tectonic plate boundaries that exist.
Introduction/Motivation
Did you know that we live on gigantic moving rocks? We call these rocks tectonic plates. They are what make mountain formation possible. What happens when the Earth's 14 major tectonic plates and many minor ones are all moving around? They are bound to start bumping into each other! Natural phenomena such as earthquakes, mountain formation, and volcanoes occur at plate boundaries. Mountains are usually formed at what are called convergent plate boundaries, meaning a boundary at which two plates are moving towards one another. This type of boundary eventually results in a collision. Tectonic plate collisions take a long time, as plates only shift a few centimeters each year, but they can still be powerful enough to form the Earth's largest mountain ranges!
So what happens when the convergent plates finally collide? Well, a few different possibilities can occur. Sometimes, the two tectonic plates press up against each other, causing the land to lift into mountainous forms as the plates continue to collide. Another possibility is that one plate pushes on top of the other, sending it downward into the Earth! We call this a subduction zone. The mountains formed from this powerful compressive process are called complex mountains.
Given these options, how do we know which possibility will occur? It depends on the composition of the tectonic plates involved in the collision. Tectonic plates are either made up of oceanic crust or continental crust. Oceanic crust is mainly made of basaltic rocks, and continental crust is mainly made of felsic rocks. Basaltic rocks are denser than felsic rocks; therefore, oceanic crust is denser than continental crust. So, if an oceanic tectonic plate collides with a continental plate, the denser oceanic plate is likely to sink beneath the continental plate, creating a subduction zone. If, however, two continental plates (therefore of similar density) smack into one another, they, instead, lift up against one another.
Let's look at some diagrams. (By paper handout or overhead projection, show students what happens in the various plate convergence scenarios, as shown in the attached Tectonic Plates Convergence Handout-Overhead.)
Now that we have talked about complex mountains, let's briefly touch on two other types of mountains. Fault-block mountains are formed by an entirely different process. These mountains are produced when tectonic plates are stretched to the point that they crack and slide. These cracks, or vertical faults, are fractures in the continental crust. Crust is then squeezed upward between the two parallel lines, resulting in mountains! And finally, the term erosional mountain describes mountains that are formed due to the erosion of uplifted rocks in the Earth's geography. This process occurs when rivers, over time, carve away at a region of uplifted geography.
But bumps and hills are all over this planet — so what constitutes a mountain? Mountains are landforms that extend above their surrounding areas in a limited area. That is a very general definition! No required elevation exists for a mountain to be called a mountain, so what makes a mountain different from a hill? Mountains are generally considered to be higher and steeper than a hill, but the definitions ultimately depend on local custom. A hill to some is a mountain to others, and visa versa!
These tunnels in Nevada enable traffic on US interstate highway 80 to continue through a mountain of rock instead of going around it.
Geotechnical engineers study mountains and the movement of tectonic plates for a variety of purposes. They observe plate movements to design technologies to measure the movement of tectonic plates and mountain formation in order to predict earthquakes and how to best protect people from them. Using these technologies, they develop processes and rules for developing communities and roadways around tectonic plate movement (adding extra support requirements to structures on an earthquake fault line). They also use the information to develop technologies that predict locations at which geothermal, oil, natural gas and coal resources may be located. Sometimes geotechnical engineers work with other engineers to turn the geological formations themselves into resources for humans, such as mountain tunnels, dams and roads. After completing the lesson refer to the hands-on associated activity Tunnel Through! to have student teams model the challenges of engineering a tunnel through a mountain for transportation purposes .
Lesson Background and Concepts for Teachers
The Earth's internal structure makes the land and oceans prone to mountain formation. The lithosphere, Earth's rigid top layer of rock, floats on the asthenosphere, Earth's hot, malleable layer beneath the lithosphere. The rigid lithosphere layer is about 100 km (60 miles) thick and makes up the Earth's enormous moving rocks called tectonic plates; 14 major tectonic plates and 38 minor plates are identified. (The Earth's major tectonic plates are the African, Antarctic, Arabian, Australian, Caribbean, Cocos, Eurasian, Indian, Juan de Fuca, Nazca, North American, Pacific, Philippine, and South American Plates.) Tectonic plates are further classified into two major groups based upon their composition: oceanic crust and continental crust. Typically, a single tectonic plate can contain both oceanic and continental crust. Oceanic crust is mainly comprised of basaltic rocks, whereas continental crust is largely made up of felsic rocks, which are lower in density.
Currents acting on the asthenosphere push the Earth's tectonic plates in lateral movements. Because the lithosphere essentially floats on the asthenosphere, movement in the asthenosphere gets transferred to the lithosphere, causing the Earth's tectonic plates to move in different directions. The currents causing this movement in the asthenosphere are not entirely understood, but the Earth's internal heat engine is the hypothesized cause.
Three types of tectonic pl ate boundaries exist: convergent, divergent and transform. Mountains are formed by plate convergence. Plate convergence describes tectonic plate movement that results in the collision of two plates. These slow-moving collisions shift the plates only a few centimeters a year, but are powerful enough to form large mountain ranges over time.
Plate convergence resulting in mountain formation occurs in several ways. First, two tectonic plates can be pressed up against each other until the land lifts and folds over itself. If the two plates involved in the process contain continental crust, it is called a continental collision. Second, one plate can push on top of another, causing the latter to slide downward into the Earth. This is called a subduction zone (when one plate moves underneath the other). At that place, it begins to melt, leading melted rock to escape through cracks and weak spots, and burst out as fiery volcanoes. Third, tectonic plates can stretch until they crack and slide, resulting in fault-block mountains. And finally, underwater mountains are formed when tectonic plates spread away from one another, allowing melted rock to push up through the gap. This process is more common, as mountain formation occurs more often in oceans than on land.
Because mountain peaks experience higher elevations than their surrounding areas, they also experience cold temperatures in higher layers of the atmosphere. Mountains therefore often experience glaciation, when glaciers carve and shape mountain peaks by carrying rocks with them as their ice melts or shifts downward. This process carves sharp horns, rounded bowls, and u-shaped valleys into mountains, creating the images that come to mind when we think about mountains. Mountains can also change shape due to other natural elements such as rain, wind or ice wearing away the rock. Eventually, previously high jagged peaks naturally become low rounded hills and ultimately wear down into soil, sand or sediments.
Now that we've talked about mountain formation, describe for me the outer layers of the Earth (Listen and clarify student descriptions). Explain how tectonic plate movement is linked to the formation of mountain ranges. (Listen and clarify student descriptions.) How is this information important to the daily lives of many people? (Listen and add to student answers.) In today's fast-paced world, people who want to get from one side of a mountain to the other prefer the quickest route—driving through! Who are the people responsible for designing tunnels? (Engineers make driving directly through mountains a possibility by designing and constructing mountain tunnels, saving countless travelers, haulers, commuters, emergency vehicles, truckers and vacationers time on the road each day.
Vocabulary/Definitions
asthenosphere: Earth's malleable layer located beneath the lithosphere.
basaltic: Gray to black volcanic rocks.
complex mountains: Mountains formed due to tectonic plates being subjected to large compressive forces.
continental collision: Two plates in motion toward one another cause mountain formation and the collision of two continents.
continental crust: The part of the lithosphere that forms the continents. This material is less dense than oceanic crust, but is considerably thicker.
convergent plates: Two tectonic plates in motion toward one another.
divergent plates: Two tectonic plates in motion away from one another.
fault-block mountains: Mountains formed when continental tectonic plates stretch to the point that they crack and slide.
felsic: Refers to silicate minerals, magmas, and rocks that contain lighter elements such as silica, oxygen, aluminum, sodium and potassium.
lithosphere: Earth's rigid outer layer, consisting of the crust and outermost mantle.
oceanic crust: The part of the lithosphere found in the ocean. This crust is generally composed of mafic basaltic rocks and is denser than continental crust.
subduction zone: When one tectonic plate moves beneath another at a plate boundary. This takes place at convergent plate boundaries if one or both of the tectonic plates at the boundary is made of oceanic crust.
tectonic plates: Large sections that make up the Earth's lithosphere.
transform plates: Two plates that slide and grind against each other in a horizontal direction along a transform fault.
Assessment
Pre-Lesson Assessment
Class Discussion: Ask students what they know about mountain formation to see if they can explain it to you before launching into the lesson.
Post-Introduction Assessment
Class Vote: Give the students several True/False statements about the lesson material and have them vote on whether they think the answers are true or false.
True or False: The asthenosphere is located below the lithosphere. (Answer: True)
True or False: The Earth has total tectonic plates. (Answer: False. 14 major tectonic plates, plus numerous [~38] minor ones.)
True or False: Oceanic crust is denser than continental crust. (Answer: True)
True or False: Mountains can be formed at convergent plate boundaries. (Answer: True)
True or False: The lithosphere is Earth's rigid surface layer. (Answer: False. The asthenosphere is Earth's rigid surface layer. The lithosphere is Earth's hot malleable layer located beneath the asthenosphere.)
Lesson Summary Assessment
Student-Generated Questions: Have each student come up with one question to ask the rest of the class on the lesson topic. They should each know the answer to their question! Be prepared to help some students form questions. Have students take turns asking their questions to the class or collect the questions and answers to ask them back to the class in a random order.
Homework
Peak to Peak: Have each student research a mountain range. How was it formed and when? What makes the mountain range unique? Have them present their findings to the class or turn in a written paragraph.
Lesson Extension Activities
If you live near a mountain range, have a geologist take your class on a hike and talk about the formation of your local range and rock composition.
Have students recreate a mountain range using clay and present it to the class. Require their models to be topographically accurate and to scale.
Have students research the Earth's tectonic plates. Are any current movements expected to result in mountain formation?
Subscribe
Get the inside scoop on all things TeachEngineering such as new site features, curriculum updates, video releases, and more by signing up for our newsletter!
PS: We do not share personal information or emails with anyone.
References
Cameron, Ward. 2005. Understanding the Formation of the Rocky Mountains. www.MountainNature.com, Field Guide for the Next Millennium. Accessed September 3, 2008.
Convergent Plate Boundaries, USGS Geology in the Parks. Last updated January 13, 2004.US Geological Survey, US Department of the Interior. Accessed September 3, 2008. http://wrgis.wr.usgs.gov/
WVGES Geology: Mountains. Last revised July 9, 2004. West Virginia Geological and Economic Survey. Accessed September 3, 2008. http://www.wvgs.wvnet.edu/
Marissa Hagan Forbes; Malinda Schaefer Zarske; Denise W. Carlson
Supporting Program
Integrated Teaching and Learning Program, College of Engineering, University of Colorado Boulder
Acknowledgements
The contents of this digital library curriculum were developed under grants from the Fund for the Improvement of Postsecondary Education (FIPSE), U.S. Department of Education and National Science Foundation (GK-12 grant no. 0338326). However, these contents do not necessarily represent the policies of the Department of Education or National Science Foundation, and you should not assume endorsement by the federal government.
Workers look at the TBM cutterhead after it reached daylight in April 1997, after a 2.5-year journey excavating through Yucca Mountain, NV. TBM is a tunnel boring machine.
Students apply their knowledge about mountains and rocks to transportation engineering, with the task of developing a model mountain tunnel that simulates the principles behind real-life engineering design. Student teams design and create model tunnels through a clay mountain, working within design constraints and testing for success; the tunnels must meet specific design requirements and withstand a certain load.
Engineering Connection
To support our world's high demand for transportation routes, many types of engineers (civil, environmental, architectural, mechanical, electrical, etc.) work together to ways to create safe and efficient travel through mountains, over water, and in varying climates. Creation of tunnel boring machines (TBMs) improved the process of drilling through rock with an alternative to drilling and blasting methods. Mountain tunnel construction using TBMs results in smooth tunnel walls, reducing the costs of lining the tunnel, and causes fewer disruptions to the surrounding natural environment. Additional tunnel and roadway engineering tasks include design of air quality testing, ventilation and lighting systems; back-up generators; and safety considerations.
Learning Objectives
After this activity, students should be able to:
Describe the process used in creating mountain tunnels.
List several types of engineers that are involved in the final design of a mountain tunnel.
List several engineering design constraints involved in the creation of a mountain tunnel.
Materials List
Each group needs:
10 Popsicle sticks
five 10 cm lengths of wire or pipe cleaner
cardboard square, at least 20cm square (for a student working surface)
Visit [www.teachengineering.org/curriculum/print/cub_rock_curricularunit] to print or download.
Introduction/Motivation
What are the different ways that people can travel or transport items to a city on the other side of a mountain? Well, they can usually travel over the over the mountain or through the mountain. What are the advantages to having a mountain tunnel for transportation? What about weather? Is the driving weather more likely to be better on top of a mountain or inside of it? Fog and snow at high mountain elevations are more likely to cause roads that cross over mountains to be closed, while roads passing through are safe and dry inside! The engineering of mountain tunnels allows us to transport goods and people through mountains in much less time than driving over or around a mountain. Approximately one-quarter of the Earth's landmass is covered with mountains, so ways to cross around or through mountains make up a substantial part of transportation engineering.
These mountain tunnels in Nevada enable traffic on US interstate highway 80 to continue through a mountain of rock instead of going around it.
The methods used for mountain tunnel construction are distinctive from those used for various other types of tunnel construction. Because mountain tunnels are often created by making a hole through sturdy rock layers, the process requires very little extra support during construction. For example, during underground tunnel construction, lumber forms are usually needed to keep the surrounding soil area from caving in. Mountain conditions, however, naturally provide sturdy rock surroundings during the drilling, eliminating the need for supplemental support. Since it is possible for different layers and hardness of rocks to be present within a mountain area, engineers determine the types of rock in the mountain before any construction begins. Sometimes engineers use materials to reinforce the interior of a tunnel from shifting rocks.
When engineers first started designing tunnels through mountains, they used the tools and process available at the time — mostly dynamite explosives. One drawback of this approach was the unintentional side effect of creating "sinkholes" inside the tunnel. Sinkholes in the tunnel floor required the addition of concrete or other material to even up the roadway inconsistencies. Today, however, engineers have developed new technologies that help them drill through mountains. Tunnel boring machines (TBMs) can bore through everything from hard rock to fine sand, and the machines themselves can m_easure up to 15 meters in diameter! Unlike the unconstrained techniques involving blasting, mountain tunnel construction using TBMs produces smooth tunnel walls with fewer disruptions to the surrounding natural environment.
Engineering of mountain tunnels goes far beyond boring enormous holes through mountain sides. Engineers also design air quality testing and ventilation systems, safety factors, lighting systems, and back-up generators for tunnel power — among countless other details necessary to make tunnels ready for transportation. This means architectural, environmental, civil, mechanical and electrical engineers are all involved in the final design of a mountain tunnel.
Today, you are going to practice being a transportation engineer with the assignment of designing a tunnel to go through a mountain. You will create and test a model of your design and explore design improvements.
Make model clay mountains (mounds) that are ~ 12cm high by 15cm in diameter. Place each mountain on a piece of cardboard. Make enough for one per group.
With the Students: Day 1-Tunnel Design
Review the overall activity procedure with the students: Working in teams, you will design and create model tunnels through your clay mountains. On Day 1, you will design your procedures for boring rock out of the mountain, and build your tunnels. On Day 2, you will test your tunnels by 1) pouring water over the mountains to test for cracks or openings, and 2) applying weight to test your tunnels for structural strength.
Review the engineering design constraints: Each team's final tunnel will be rated (given points) for meeting the following design requirements:
Tunnel dimensions: Each group's tunnel must measure at least 4cm wide by 6cm high and go completely through the mountain.
The amount of material used in tunnel development and construction (Engineers strive to create the best structure possible by using the fewest materials as possible, hence, the least costly!)
Completed tunnel development in the assigned time period
Insulation of tunnel from weather (no water leaks into the tunnel)
Structural strength (The mountain does not collapse under added weight)
Environmental impacts (Does the tunnel change the mountain structure?)
Divide the class into groups of two students each.
Distribute the worksheet. Have each group brainstorm how they will bore a hole through their mountain and sketch their tunnel design idea on the worksheet. Remind students that engineers do not just start building — they carefully discuss and design first!
Distribute materials and model clay mountains to each group.
Give students a limited amount of time (~ 30-40 minutes) to construct their tunnels through their clay mountains on their cardboard bases.
With the Students: Day 2-Tunnel Testing
Have students take turns testing their tunnel structures for cracks (by pouring water over their structure while at a sink or over a large basin) and structural strength (by placing weights or heavy books on their mountain top).
Assign points to each group and determine the winning team. (35 possible points)
Tunnel dimensions: Each group's tunnel must measure at least 4cm wide by 6cm high and go completely through the mountain. (5 points)
The amount of materials used in tunnel development and construction (1 bonus point for each provided Popsicle stick or wire piece that a team does not use)
Completed tunnel development in the assigned time (5 points)
Insulation of tunnel from weather (no water leaks in) (5 points)
Structural strength (The mountain does not collapse under added weight) (5 points)
Environmental impacts (Tunnel does not change mountain structure) (5 points)
Lead a class discussion about what worked, what did not work, and why. See the engineering communication and environmental impacts suggestions in the Assessment section.
If time permits, give teams time to redesign their structures based upon their tests.
Re-test new designs and see if improvements were made.
Vocabulary/Definitions
Constraint: (engineering) A limitation or restriction placed on an engineering design solution. For example, specified materials, cost, time, size, etc. Also related to requirements and specifications.
Model: (noun) A representation of something, sometimes on a smaller scale. (verb) To simulate, make or construct something to help visualize or learn about something else (such as a machine, structure, process or system), often something that cannot be directly observed or experimented upon.
TBM: Acronym for a tunnel boring machine. A machine that excavates tunnels with a circular cross-section through a variety of rock strata. Moving forward like an earthworm, it uses a rotating cutting wheel to excavate soil and rock that is carried away by a conveyor belt system.
Transportation engineer: A type of civil engineer that works on the safe and efficient movement of people and/or goods.
Tunnel: A hollow, covered passageway that horizontally moves through or under an obstruction.
Assessment
Pre-Activity Assessment
Brainstorming: Ask students some open-ended questions to get them thinking about mountains and tunnel construction. Remind students that in brainstorming, all ideas should be respectfully heard; no idea or suggestion is "silly." Take an uncritical position, encourage wild ideas and discourage criticism of ideas. Have students raise their hands to respond. Ask the students:
• Who has driven through a mountain before? How do you think engineers built the tunnel? Would you rather drive over a mountain or through one? Why?
Class Discussion: As a class, discuss what engineers who are designing a mountain tunnel should consider in their design about the rock layers? (Possible answers include: What type of rock[s] and soil are in the mountain, how soft or hard the rock[s] is, are any different rock layers present in the mountain.)
Activity Embedded Assessment
Observations: Observe each team as they create their models. Engage them with questions about their design and construction choices, such as: Why did you decide on this design? Do you think this design is sturdy? Why did you decide on this method/approach? What tools do you have that would be most effective at tunneling through the mountain? Why? How is your tunneling impacting the mountain? Did you reinforce your tunnel? Are you using your time and materials wisely?).
Post-Activity Assessment
Engineering Communication: As a class, discuss the various tunnel models created by the teams. If the class size allows, have students teams sit in a circle, each presenting their models to the class and explaining their ideas. Talk about what worked, what did not work, and how they would modify their designs if they could do it all over again.
Environmental Impacts: Have students talk about what they did with the clay that they removed from the mountain while digging their tunnels. How did they dispose of the unneeded material? What could engineers do with the rock and soil removed from mountains as they make tunnels? How might the creation of a tunnel through a mountain change the surrounding environment of the mountain?
Investigating Questions
Have you ever been in a mountain tunnel? What was it like?
How do you think engineers create mountain tunnels?
Why are mountain tunnels important?
Activity Extensions
Railway tunnel with pedestrian access in Frankfurt, Germany.
Have each student research and write about a famous tunnel, describing its unique engineering design challenges. This might include subways and aqueducts, as well as roadway, railroad, utility and underwater tunnels. See the list provided at Wikipedia, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tunnel#Underwater_tunnels.
Have students interview local engineers about their experiences with tunnel construction.
Activity Scaling
For lower grades, simplify or eliminate the tunnel dimension requirements.
For upper grades, add design or construction requirements and/or further limit the materials available for their design.
Additional Multimedia Support
Direct students with extra time to WGBH Building Big's online Tunnel Challenge, at which students can choose a location (through mountain, beneath city or under river), pick a tunnel-digging technique and see how long it takes to dig a mile-long tunnel:http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/buildingbig/tunnel/challenge/index.html
Direct students to learn about tunnel digging tools and techniques (fire-setting, hand tools, explosives, compressed air drill, tunnel boring machine and tunnel shield) at WGBH Building Big's online website: http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/buildingbig/tunnel/challenge/tools/index.html
Subscribe
Get the inside scoop on all things TeachEngineering such as new site features, curriculum updates, video releases, and more by signing up for our newsletter!
PS: We do not share personal information or emails with anyone.
References
Building Big: Tunnel Basics. PBS Online, WGBH Educational Foundation. Accessed September 3, 2008. http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/
Planning the Metro, The Copenhagen Metro. http://intl.m.dk/about+the=metro/construction/planning.aspx, accessed September 3, 2008.
Marissa Hagan Forbes; Malinda Schaefer Zarske; Denise W. Carlson
Supporting Program
Integrated Teaching and Learning Program, College of Engineering, University of Colorado Boulder
Acknowledgements
The contents of these digital library curricula were developed by the Integrated Teaching and Learning Program under National Science Foundation GK-12 grant no. 0338326. However, these contents do not necessarily represent the policies of the National Science Foundation, and you should not assume endorsement by the federal government.
Students learn the basics about soil, including its formation through the cycling of the Earth's materials, as well as its characteristics and importance. They are also introduced to soil profiles and how engineers conduct site investigations to learn about soil quality for development, contamination transport, and assessing the general environmental health of an area.
Engineering Connection
Geotechnical engineers apply their expertise about soil and rocks to the development of foundations for a variety of structures. In advance of any design or construction, they conduct environmental site assessments in areas proposed for development and make suggestions based on soil properties. They learn about the composition and condition of soil in an area and predict the long-term effects of that soil on walls, foundations, septic systems and countless other structures that are integral to our daily lives. For example, some clay soils have a tendency to shrink and swell as their water content changes, often triggered by changes in seasons and precipitation. This expansive property can put pressure on the walls of structures and damage them.
Learning Objectives
After this lesson, students should be able to:
Describe several physical properties of soil.
Describe how soil is formed through the cycling of Earth's materials.
Explain what a soil profile is and how engineers use it to determine an area's soil quality.
Introduction/Motivation
What is soil? Where does it come from? Soil develops from a parent rock being broken down into small particles over thousands of years due to two major processes: erosion and weathering. Erosion is when rocks disintegrate due to the movement of elements such as water, wind or ice, caused by the flow of energy and the cycling of the Earth's materials. Weathering is when rocks disintegrate simply due to contact with the atmosphere. Both processes can vary greatly by location and over time, resulting in many different types of soils. In other words, many types of soils exist because of differences in parent rock material, climate, topography and time.
Average soil composition.
What is soil and why is it important? Soil has allowed for the existence of many life forms we know today. It provides plants with a place to grow and meets most of their nutritional needs. Soil that is able to support plant life is made of both organic and inorganic matter. Organic matter is matter that is biological. The soil's organic matter includes materials that are capable of being decayed, like decomposing plants and the remains of once-living organisms. Inorganic matter is matter that comes from mineral. Inorganic matter in soil includes things such as weathered rock and minerals, as well as air and water. An average soil consists of about 95% inorganic matter and 5% organic matter.
Of the 5% organic matter found in average soil, 80% of that organic matter is in the form of humus (with another 10% as roots and 10% as organisms). Humus is a dark brown or black substance naturally found in the soil. So where does humus come from? Organisms living in the soil naturally add organic matter to their surroundings, and when fungi and bacteria decompose, this organic matter, humus is formed. Larger organisms, such as earthworms, later spread the humus into deeper layers, further developing the soil and making it possible for plants to grow.
Profile of silty clay loam soil from Cannon County, TN. The limestone bedrock (parent material) begins at a depth of 16 inches (41 cm).
Have you ever taken a closer look at soil? Is it the same (homogenous) throughout? Erosion, decomposition and weathering all contribute to soil naturally developing in layers. If you looked at a cross-section of some soil in the ground (when you look at a side view) you might see at least three horizontal layers: the topsoil, sub-soil and bedrock. We call this cross-section view a soil profile. The topsoil is the dark top layer of soil that extends 15 to 20 cm below the surface of the Earth. Air, water and humus are present in the topsoil, helping plants to grow in this layer. The sub-soil layer is found below the topsoil, and has many clay-like characteristics; it acts as a reservoir for storing water that plants need. Below the sub-soil is bedrock. Bedrock is sometimes referred to as parent material because both the topsoil and sub-soil originate from the rocks that make up the bedrock.
Geotechnical engineering is a branch of civil engineering that works with rocks, soils and Earth materials. To make recommendations for building on a specific piece of land, geotechnical engineers first take a look at the surface and subsurface conditions of an area. The engineers might draw a soil profile during a site assessment. Site assessments are investigations of the Earth that take place before some other engineering is performed, such as designing a community of houses or even a research area in a wilderness park. The engineers must find out what types of soils and rock they are working with before they spend the money to design and build something on top of it. Geotechnical engineers look at many soil properties when conducting site investigations. They may look at color, types of mineral present, material weight, porosity (or how much air is in the soil), permeability of the soil (how much water can flow through it), and how much stress or force the soil can undergo without changing.
Besides building large structures or fixing existing structures that are falling down, other reasons exist for why engineers might investigate the soil in an area. Environmental engineers look at soils to determine the health of the area. They may take several soil samples to determine where a toxic contaminant spill is located that is affecting the health of the people in the community. They may also use soil samples to follow the path of water or pollution through the ground, or to search for specific minerals or fossil fuels. Agricultural engineers study soil samples to determine how to help crops grow better. Other engineers investigate soils to see how they are changing and how the change effects threatened wildlife and plant species. Students can act as engineers in the associated activity Soil Core Sampling where they learn more about the benefits and steps of soil sampling. Soils are very important to life on Earth and engineers help us protect those soils and decide where to best grow our communities without destroying the healthy soil.
The different processes that determine the properties of soil (as well as minerals and rocks) are the result of the flow of the Earth's energy and the cycling of materials. The energy that drives these processes comes from the sun and the Earth's interior. Weathering is one process that results from this cycle and drives the changes in Earth's materials and organisms. Specifically, two main types of weathering affect the components of soil: physical and chemical. Physical weathering describes the breakdown of rocks and soils due to atmospheric conditions, such as temperature, water or pressure. Chemical weathering describes the impact of chemicals (either produced biologically or by the atmosphere) on the breakdown of rocks and soils.
Humus enables soil to hold more moisture and provides plants with their primary source of carbon and nitrogen, all of which benefit soil by making it better at supporting plant growth. To understand humus, it would be helpful to look at it, but it is difficult to see humus alone because it is bound to larger particles in the soil.
Plant roots located in deeper layers of the soil require air and water for growth and survival. Air and water is present in the topsoil, but must be transferred to the deeper layers by mixing and aeration. This process can occur naturally with the help of earthworms and other insects. Earthworms that spread humus to deeper layers of soil are also paramount in mixing and aeration. In fact, these two phenomena are closely related. The term translocation describes the process in which water moving through soil simultaneously causes other materials in the soil (such as humus) to move and spread.
Various environmental factors impact the color of soil in both the horizontal and vertical directions. For example, a soil that contains more humus is darker than one with a more moderate amount. Iron and aluminum in some soils undergo chemical reactions that cause the soil to turn shades of red and yellow. Many additional coloring materials are found in soils.
Lesson Closure
Now that you have learned the basics about soil, explain to me what soil is and how it is formed. (Listen to student descriptions.) Soil is able to support plant life; it is made up of both organic and inorganic matter. The three main horizontal layers of soil are: the topsoil, sub-soil and bedrock. Most of the soil we see is topsoil. Topsoil contains amounts of air, water and humus and is a good place for plants to grow.
Geotechnical engineering is a type of civil engineering that specializes in understanding rocks, soils and Earth materials. These engineers take soil samples and create soil profiles to determine if an area is good for the placing a building or structure. Environmental engineers look at soil samples to determine if pollution is in the soil, the effects of developments on soil, or the location of minerals and fossil fuels. They look carefully to see if the changes in soil affect the plants and animals that live in the area. Agricultural engineers study soil samples to make recommendations for growing crops. Soil is an important part of life and engineers help us use the soil to learn about our impact on the Earth.
Vocabulary/Definitions
chemical weathering: The disintegration of rocks and soils due to chemicals produced biologically or by the atmosphere.
erosion: The disintegration of rocks and soils due to wind, water, ice or other processes. This process occurs with movement.
horizons: Layers of a soil profile.
inorganic matter: Materials that originate from mineral sources.
leaching: The process of extracting a substance.
organic matter: Materials of biological origin that are capable of being decayed.
physical weathering: The disintegration of rocks and soils due to atmospheric conditions such as heat, water or pressure.
soil profile: A cross-section through the soil. This side-view angle shows a soil's layers.
translocation: When water moves through soil causing materials in the soil to move and spread.
weathering: The disintegration of rocks and soils due to contact with the atmosphere. This process occurs without movement.
Assessment
Pre-Lesson Assessment
Brainstorming: In small groups, have students engage in open discussion. Remind them that in brainstorming, no idea or suggestion is "silly." All ideas should be respectfully heard. Encourage wild ideas and discourage criticism of ideas. Ask the students:
What is soil?
From where does it come?
What processes form soil?
Post-Introduction Assessment
Drawings: Have students draw a cross-section view of a soil sample. Direct them to label the soil layers and incorporate symbols of what might be found in that layer. For example, draw plants and roots, or use little As for air or Ws for water. Communicate the differences between the soil layers with color or fill patterns to show density of the soil layer. Have students also incorporate what processes could have contributed to the formation of their soil by drawing arrows and labeling possible explanations. Have students estimate what percent each layer makes up the whole. Students should write a percentage next to the soil layer and be able to give an explanation as to why they believe that layer takes up that percentage. Have students explain their soil profiles and the relationship to material cycling and weathering processes to other students in the class.
Lesson Summary Assessment
Soil Investigation: Have students think about the soil in either your area or one that you assign. What is the climate like? How does that affect the topsoil? How does the soil compare to the soil in other parts of the world? If they were geotechnical engineers, what types of things might they communicate about the soil in their areas?
Lesson Extension Activities
As an extension, consider teaching A Good Foundation lesson and Shallow and Deep Foundations activity in the Bridges unit, in which students explore the effects of regional geology on bridge foundation, including the variety of soil conditions found beneath foundations. They learn about shallow and deep foundations, as well as the concepts of soil profiles, bearing pressure and settlement.
See the Natural Resources Conservation Service webpage with several hands-on lesson extension options: http://soil.gsfc.nasa.gov/
Subscribe
Get the inside scoop on all things TeachEngineering such as new site features, curriculum updates, video releases, and more by signing up for our newsletter!
PS: We do not share personal information or emails with anyone.
References
Introduction to Soil. Last updated March 15, 2000. Greater Johannesburg Metropolitan Council. Accessed September 10, 2008. http://ceroi.net/reports/johannesburg/csoe/html/nonjava/Soil/intro.htm
Levine, Elissa. Touch the Earth: Introduction to Soils. Last updated June 2, 2005. Soil Science Education, Goddard Space Flight Center, NASA. Accessed September 10, 2008. http://soil.gsfc.nasa.gov/
Pidwirny, Michael. (2006). Introduction to Soils. Last updated April 17, 2008. Fundamentals of Physical Geography, 2nd Edition. Chapter 10: Introduction to Lithosphere, University of British Columbia, Okanagan. Accessed September 10, 2008. http://www.physicalgeography.net/fundamentals/10t.html
Marissa Hagan Forbes; Malinda Schaefer Zarske; Denise W. Carlson
Supporting Program
Integrated Teaching and Learning Program, College of Engineering, University of Colorado Boulder
Acknowledgements
The contents of this digital library curriculum were developed under grants from the Fund for the Improvement of Postsecondary Education (FIPSE), U.S. Department of Education and National Science Foundation (GK-12 grant no. 0338326). However, these contents do not necessarily represent the policies of the Department of Education or National Science Foundation, and you should not assume endorsement by the federal government.
Students learn about one method used in environmental site assessments. They practice soil sampling by creating soil cores, studying soil profiles and characterizing soil profiles in borehole logs. They use their analyses to make predictions about what is going on in the soil and what it might mean to engineers developing the area.
Engineering Connection
Geotechnical engineers are involved in environmental site assessments that analyze the impact of development on the land. To make recommendations based on soil quality, engineers drill small-diameter boreholes into the ground to collect soil samples. Soil is removed from boreholes in long clear tubes called soil cores. Soil cores permit engineers to examine many feet of the below-ground soil profile. Engineers use the soil cores to characterize the soil profile using borehole logs. They also take soil samples and further analyze them for characteristics, quality, water content, and pollutant or pesticide contamination.
Learning Objectives
After this activity, students should be able to:
Describe how soil samples are taken by engineers for site assessment.
Analyze a model soil core sample and make recommendations for development on similar areas of soil.
Materials List
Each group needs:
ruler
6-inch (15-cm) clear test tube, or any long, cylindrical object, so long as it is clear (so the soil layers can be seen), even plastic soda and water bottles with the top necks cut off
1 cardboard box (or plastic box or bin), at least 30cm wide x 45cm long x 20 cm high, in which to layer soil types
sand, such as playground sand
gravel, such as pea-sized playground gravel
soil, such as potting soil
dirt
clay
Note: Exact material quantities necessary for the activity will vary depending upon class size. Obtain enough materials to create a layered soil sample in the box.
Visit [www.teachengineering.org/curriculum/print/cub_rock_curricularunit] to print or download.
Pre-Req Knowledge
Basic knowledge of rock and soil types.
Introduction/Motivation
What would happen if your house or this school was built on unstable soils? If part of the soil started sinking, the building might crack or move. Engineers help us make sure that buildings and other structures are built on stable soils, decreasing the risk of building failure due to unstable soil.
Before a restaurant, office tower, house, bridge or any other building is constructed, geotechnical engineers conduct environmental site assessments, which include soil tests, in the areas proposed for development. They examine soil samples to learn about the underground composition of the soils in the area, and make predictions of the long-term effects the soil at the site might have on the walls, foundation, septic system or any other components to the proposed structure. Some soils, such as clays, have a tendency to shrink and swell when their water content changes. This expansive property can put pressure on structure and foundation walls and cause them damage. Other soils are poor at settling or sinking under weight, causing uneven ground. Foundations that are built on these soils are at risk for cracking or bending.
How do you suppose they find out what type of soil is in the area? (Take suggestions from students.) They drill into the ground and look at the layers of Earth in the form of soil cores. A soil core is a vertical view (or soil profile) of everything below ground, contained in a long clear tube. The core tube contains soil that is removed from a hole drilled in the ground, or a borehole. In real life, each soil core is usually only several feet in length. However, the drill rig used to take the soil core can take more than one in the same place. For example, if a company was drilling a 20-ft (6-m) borehole, and each soil core tube was 3-ft (1-m) in length, the drill rig would take about seven soil cores during the drilling.
At this Colorado home, soil cores are taken to a depth of 25 feet (7.6 m) and examined to look for expansive bentonite clays before digging a basement and pouring a concrete foundation.
Soil cores are taken whenever someone needs to look at the properties and types of soil in an area. Environmental engineers may study soil cores to determine where the water table is located in the ground (for water resources), or how fast a chemical or contaminant spill has soaked into the ground during contaminant cleanup. These engineers can also tell how fast the contaminant is spreading through the different layers of Earth by taking multiple soil cores in and around an area and measuring the amount of contamination as it moves further away from the spill site.
Today, we are going to take soil cores from a sample piece of Earth and analyze the different soils in our sample. We will use what we find to answer some questions about the area during a site assessment.
Procedure
Before the Activity
Create a model piece of Earth by filling a box (or bin) to approximately 6-8 inches (15 cm) deep with layers of various soil materials. Start with a layer of clay or denser soil at the bottom of the box, so that the rest of the layers stay in the test tube when removed. (The clay or dense/damp soil acts as a stopper for the test tube.) A suggestion: At the bottom, start with one-inch (2.5-cm) layers each of clay, then dirt. Then alternate layers of the rest of the materials on top of them.
Gather the rest of the materials and make copies of the Soil Core Worksheet, one per team.
With the Students
Divide the class into teams of two students each.
Distribute one worksheet and one clear test tube to each group.
Explain to students that as engineers, they will be taking a soil core form the box of Earth that you have created. They start by using wire, tape and cardboard to create a device (with a handle and wedge) to help them insert the test tube into the soil. (Engineers design tools all the time!)
Give the students 30 minutes to design and build their test tube inserting devices. Have them follow along with this process on their worksheet.
Guide students to discuss and evaluate their tool design. How will they evaluate their tool design? What criteria? Did their tool work effectively? Is it a good size? How long does it take to use the device? Was it strong enough? Did it break? Etc.
Next, have student teams take turns retrieving a soil core from the box. Have them return to their seats and complete the analysis portion of their worksheets by filling out the borehole logs while examining their test tube samples. A borehole log (see Figure 1) is what soil engineers use to describe soil cores so that they have a written record of what the inside of a borehole looks like, so they do not need to take the actual sample back to the office.
Have students measure each layer of their soil cores, visually representing them in the Graphic Section columns of the borehole logs, as well as describing in words each layer's color and grain. Also direct students to calculate the fraction (percentage) of the soil that was composed by each layer.
Have students complete the questions at the bottom of the worksheets, imagining that they are engineers doing a site assessment for a development company.
Lead a class discussion to review the students' analysis. What would they change if they were to redesign their sampling device/tool? Would they recommend constructing a housing community on this type of soil? Why or why not? (Answers will vary, depending on the model's soil composition.)
Conclude by conducting the post-activity assessment activity described in the Assessment section.
Vocabulary/Definitions
borehole: A hole drilled in the ground.
borehole log: A method of detailing a soil core profile.
drill rig: Equipment used to make a hole in the ground.
model: (noun) A representation of something, sometimes on a smaller scale. (verb) To simulate, make or construct something to help visualize or learn about something else (such as a machine, structure, process or system), often something that cannot be directly observed or experimented upon.
soil core: Tube containing soil removed from borehole during drilling process.
Assessment
Pre-Activity Assessment
Discussion: Have students engage in open discussion about the different types of rocks and soils that they have learned about. Why might an engineer need to know about the type of rocks or soil in an area?
Activity Embedded Assessment
Worksheet: Have student teams complete the attached Soil Core Worksheet; review their answers to gauge their mastery of the subject.
Post-Activity Assessment
Roundtable: Have the class form into teams of 3-5 students each. Ask the class a question with several possible answers. Have students on each team make a list of answers by taking turns writing down ideas on a piece of paper. Students pass the list around the group until all ideas are exhausted. Have teams read aloud the answers and write them on the board. Ask the students:
What are properties of soil that you can learn from a soil core sample? (Possible answers: Color, density, porosity, type of soil, water content, rock and mineral content and sizes, presence of pollutants or contaminants, etc.)
Why are soil core samples useful to development of an area? (Possible answers: To determine what type of foundation material to use, know how deep to build, find hazards or obstacles to development in the area, predict the impact on the environment from building, make sure contaminants are not present, etc.)
How do engineers use soil core samples? (Possible answers: To determine the type of soil, make recommendations for foundations, locate underground water resources, look for contaminants, etc.)
Safety Issues
Be sure students do not push their test tubes into the soil with too much force; they may break.
Troubleshooting Tips
Test tube soil sampling is less messy if the lowest layers of the model box of Earth are made of clay and/or dense/damp soil, as opposed to sand or gravel.
Activity Extensions
Have each team write letters to (hypothetical) development companies describing the findings from their borehole logs. What did the borehole log tell them about the soil in that area? What recommendations would they make to a development company who was planning to create a housing development on that piece of land?
Have students calculate the amount of soil each layer would occupy if the total soil core was 10 meters instead of 15 cm. How far down would the clay layer start?
Environmental engineers use soil cores to analyze the presence and spread of pollution contamination in soils and groundwater. For an activity that has students look at a contaminant plume in groundwater, see Groundwater Detectives.
Have students think about the water table in their soil sample. At what depth do they think the water table might be found? Add moisture to some soil core layers to show moisture. (Soil cores should be moist from bedrock up to the top of the water table. Depth to the water table, or DTW, from the surface always varies by location.)
The Tower of Pisa is a widely-recognized foundation failure. Extend this activity with A Good Foundation lesson and Shallow and Deep Foundations activity in the Bridges unit, in which students explore the effects of regional geology on bridge foundation, including the variety of soil conditions found beneath foundations. They learn about shallow and deep foundations, as well as the concepts of soil profiles, bearing pressure and settlement.
Activity Scaling
For lower grades, do not require completion of fractions calculations on the worksheet. And, complete the worksheet results questions (Part 3) together, as a class discussion.
Subscribe
Get the inside scoop on all things TeachEngineering such as new site features, curriculum updates, video releases, and more by signing up for our newsletter!
PS: We do not share personal information or emails with anyone.
Marissa Hagan Forbes; Malinda Schaefer Zarske; Denise W. Carlson
Supporting Program
Integrated Teaching and Learning Program, College of Engineering, University of Colorado Boulder
Acknowledgements
The contents of these digital library curricula were developed by the Integrated Teaching and Learning Program under National Science Foundation GK-12 grant no. 0338326. However, these contents do not necessarily represent the policies of the National Science Foundation, and you should not assume endorsement by the federal government.
User Comments & Tips